,

Songs We Mistakenly Thought Black People Sang

The death of beloved Bobby Caldwell had us thinking about other excellent blue-eyed soul singers you need to know.

Jon B. Photo: Getty Images Bryan Steffy

Every so often, we will hear a song we swear was sung by a Black person. That is until you see the white singer blowing their heart out on Youtube. And all you can do is smile. The late Bobby Caldwell is the perfect example but there are many more.

Video will return here when scrolled back into view
Trump’s Tariffs Might Stick Around. What Should We Buy Now?
Trump’s Tariffs Might Stick Around. What Should We Buy Now?

Here are great songs we thought Black people sang.

Bobby Caldwell - “What You Won’t Do For Love”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8Y0SZrPdX0

We have to start with the king. When Bobby Caldwell broke into the music scene with his 1978 single, “What You Won’t Do For Love,” many people thought he was Black. But not only because of his husky soulful voice but the label he was signed to, TK Records. An R&B label, popular among the Black listeners, TK wanted to hide Caldwell’s race and did not show his face on his self-titled debut album. Fans did not discover he was white until he went on tour with Natalie Cole to promote his album.

Bobby Caldwell - “Open Your Eyes”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPgMjXhqmfw

When this song came out in 1980, people already knew Bobby was clearly a White man. But for young people who are hearing the songs decades later, I can’t imagine them guessing it’s anyone other than a Black man.

Lisa Stanfield - “All Around The World”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVuuatjHGnY

All these years later, new fans of this soulful tune are shocked to know the great songstress is a white woman from England.

Michael McDonald - “I Keep Forgettin (Every Time You’re Near)”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gbQVj4MR3M

The first time I heard this song, I thought it was a voiceover. There’s no way that voice belongs to that white man. Just look at this video reaction to this song by these young Black men and you’ll understand how I looked when I heard it.

Daryl Hall & John Oates - “I Can’t Go For That”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ccenFp_3kq8

Watching this music video, I can’t believe I thought this was a group full of Black men. Turns out, the famous two singers are white. But, you have to admit, this song right here is a bop.

Jon B. - “They Don’t Know”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5pD4nBabMk

Before Justin Timberlake, there was Jon B. This man is clearly white, but just check out the haircut and the woman in the above music video and you would’ve thought this man was Black in another lifetime.

Jon B. - “Don’t Talk”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDM-XA0-8g4

It’s still flabergasting that just about everything about this man is Black except his skin color. This was another hit of his that I really enjoyed.

Teena Marie & Rick James - “Fire and Desire”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqGWCyIsl5A

Rick James is a legend; nobody is questioning if he’s Black or not. But the soulful singing skills of his former white girlfriend/ singing cohort, the great Teena Marie, who’s featured on this track, might surprise some young people. But do know that Teena was beloved by millions of African Americans. When I first heard this song though, I thought there was no way.

Teena Marie - “Square Biz”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymzftNzqQM0

Everything about this performance is Black, except the woman singing. The backup singers, the band, everything.

Foxy - “Get Off”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6lqTTyKeCs

I remember hearing this song in the 2005 movie Roll Bounce. I swore it was sung by a Black person until I learned that Focy was a 1970s Latin/disco band.

KC & The Sunshine Band - “That’s The Way (I Like It)”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0_H3F84Yjk

Okay, this one genuinely shocked me. I’ve heard this song my whole life. I didn’t give it a second thought, it’s clearly a song by a Black funk group. It turns out, many of the people in the group are indeed black, except the lead singer, Harry Wayne Casey.

KC & The Sunshine Band - “I Get Lifted”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hr_yaGD-O_A

KC & The Sunshine Band did it again on their 1975 track, “Get Lifted.” It still baffles me that the lead singer is a pale white man.

Average White Band - “A Love of Your Own”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXtaTmpkT8g

Like many groups on this list, Average White Band was a Funk and R&B in the 1970s and 80s. The name should be a dead giveaway. But if you listen to this track without knowing who the band is, you’ll have no idea it was packed with white men.

Dusty Springfield - “Son Of A Preacher Man”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAZLgsDRUv4

Not only is this woman white, but she’s from England. It seems that English people have a knack for putting some soul into their singers.

JoJo - “Leave (Get Out)”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWzoSy6QEwk

JoJo has been and still is... in the R&B game for a minute now. She’s one of the only white girls still active in the genre. In fact, she just released a solid album two years ago. But, if you never laid eyes on her, you might assume she was Black.

Nina Sky - “Move Ya Body”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2_E62NY3hg

Ok this probably shouldn’t be on this list because some will definitely argue the singers are part of the diaspora, and maybe true, but still. I did not know who made this song until now. I’ve heard it in countless movies from the mid-2000s. I always thought it was a young Black R&B singer from like Atlanta or Brooklyn, who came and went. Turns out it was the Puerto Rican-American duo Nina Sky.

P!nk - “Most Girls”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWJ_P-TdEJ0

Maybe this is on me, but whenever I heard people reference P!nk, I just assumed she was Black, especially when I heard this track. It sounded like your typical R&B song sung by a Black woman during the mid-2000s. You could only imagine how shocked I was when I saw a picture. I’ve even heard some Black people say they thought she was light skin.

Christina Aguilera - “Ain’t No Other Man”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x7Ta89QLo4

Christina is probably the most well-known person on this list. Everyone and their mama should know by now that Christina Aguilera is white, but that voice says something else.

Robin Thicke -” Lost Without U”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DdCoNbbRvQ

Robin Thicke is also a well-known singer, so most people already know he’s not Black. But, like Christina Aguilera...his voice, and his ex-wife, would be no indication.

Envyi - “Swing My Way”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7MEUqIlyG14

Young R&B fans should recognize this song, as it was sampled on Bryson Tiller’s popular 2015 track, “Exchange.” It’s clear that K.P. is Black, but I had no idea that the woman singing, Envyi, is not.

Straight From The Root

Sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Latest from The Root

The Ever-Growing List of Lawsuits Against Sean 'Diddy' Combs

The Ever-Growing List of Lawsuits Against Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs

Even after a "victory" in the federal case against him, Diddy still has an uphill legal battle that could cost him millions ...
Take a Look Inside Michael Jordan's Former Chicago-Area Mansion, Which You Can Now Airbnb For This Heart-Clutching Price

Take a Look Inside Michael Jordan’s Former Chicago-Area Mansion, Which You Can Now Airbnb For This Heart-Clutching Price

The iconic basketball player's old ultra-luxury living pad in Chicago can be your home for a massive price ...

Diddy's Best Friend Charlie Liucci is Being <i>Loud</i> About His Next Moves Will Be Following Acquittal

Diddy’s Best Friend Charlie Liucci is Being Loud About His Next Moves Will Be Following Acquittal

He's been spotted wearing "FREE PUFF" merch, now, Charlie Liucci has an inside scoop on what Diddy will do once released ...
How Baltimore Beat 'The Wire' Homicide Curse Under This Black Mayor

How Baltimore Beat ‘The Wire’ Homicide Curse Under This Black Mayor

Violent crime has plagued Baltimore for generations, and "The Wire's" depiction of drug and gang life surely hasn't helped... but there's hope ...
Best Self-Help Reads for Black Resilience in Uncertain Times

Best Self-Help Reads for Black Resilience in Uncertain Times

In these challenging times, these books can give you the hope you need ...
'Hey Google' and Other Voice Assistants Are Terrifying Children and Confusing Bemused Parents

‘Hey Google’ and Other Voice Assistants Are Terrifying Children and Confusing Bemused Parents

Social media is buzzing about the strange reaction kids are having to smart speakers in their homes ...
Internet Believes Eerie Photo Predicted Black Fort Worth Family's Tragedy

Internet Believes Eerie Photo Predicted Black Fort Worth Family’s Tragedy

A big rig driver admitted he fell asleep at the wheel in Kaufman County before he collided with stopped traffic ...
Why Philadelphia is Going Viral For Streets That Look Like a Landfill

Why Philadelphia is Going Viral For Streets That Look Like a Landfill

Libraries are closed, the medical examiner's office has a backlog of bodies, and trash is piling up everywhere ...
How Bakari Sellers Just Got the Ultimate Revenge on His MAGA CNN Colleague

How Bakari Sellers Just Got the Ultimate Revenge on His MAGA CNN Colleague

Sellers and Jennings often go back and forth on the CNN show, and this was only amplified when Jennings asked Sellers not to touch him during one viral interaction from December ...
The Scary Reason 'American Idol' Winner Jamal Roberts Declined a Key to This Southern Town

The Scary Reason ‘American Idol’ Winner Jamal Roberts Declined a Key to This Southern Town

While Roberts' reasoning is understandable, it's a shame he had to make the decision in the first place ...
A Black Mom Posted Video of a Terrifying Exchange She had with Police in Delaware

A Black Mom Posted Video of a Terrifying Exchange She had with Police in Delaware

Black Mom Says Cops Approached Her and Her Children With Guns Drawn ...
Why Are There Still Black People Listening To R. Kelly At The Summer Cookouts -- And What Does That Say About Us?

Why Are There Still Black People Listening To R. Kelly At The Summer Cookouts — And What Does That Say About Us?

Despite convictions and backlash, his music continues to collect streams. Why is the "Pied Piper" still on the cookout playlist? ...
How Diddy Could Still End Up With a Long Sentence, Despite The Acquittals

How Diddy Could Still End Up With a Long Sentence, Despite The Acquittals

Even with credit for time served, Diddy, 55, wouldn’t be free to break out the baby oil until 2031 ...
Why the Internet is Convinced Stephen A. Smith's And His Daughter Samantha Are Twins

Why the Internet is Convinced Stephen A. Smith’s And His Daughter Samantha Are Twins

Samantha Smith is the spitting image of her controversial sports commentator dad ...
Flint's Water Crisis Ends With A Major Development

Flint’s Water Crisis Ends With A Major Development

This milestone marks a record for one of the worst water crises in the nation's history ...
NBA's Mike Beasley's Alleged Gambling Issues Have Him Owing Money to <i>Who??</i>

NBA’s Mike Beasley’s Alleged Gambling Issues Have Him Owing Money to Who??

The amount of money Beasley apparently owes to his barber is insane ...
Diddy's Dramatic Reaction to His Trial Verdict Says it All...

Diddy’s Dramatic Reaction to His Trial Verdict Says it All…

After giving death stares to reporters and throwing up heart symbols to his children throughout the trial, Diddy's demeanor has taken a turn ...
Lizzo Reveals The Meals She Ate To Lose 100 Pounds

Lizzo Reveals The Meals She Ate To Lose 100 Pounds

The popular singer is finally sharing some secrets behind her amazing weight loss journey and we're taking notes! ...
Seven Singers That Black People Swear Can Sing, But We Know They Can't

Seven Singers That Black People Swear Can Sing, But We Know They Can’t

Can we have a frank and honest conversation? It is time we told the truth ...
Halle Bailey Debuts Potential New Man Amid DDG Drama and the Internet Says It's About Time!

Halle Bailey Debuts Potential New Man Amid DDG Drama and the Internet Says It’s About Time!

Bailey appears to be basking in her newfound happiness and a newfound man. And the social media streets are hot about it! ...