When Jim Brown Slams Kobe Bryant, Black Men Lose

There are two types of running backs: those who get the ball and dance around in the backfield waiting for a bit of daylight so they can slide through unscathed, and those who take the ball and go busting into the defense, making a path by brute force. Suggested Reading Have You Heard of The…

There are two types of running backs: those who get the ball and dance around in the backfield waiting for a bit of daylight so they can slide through unscathed, and those who take the ball and go busting into the defense, making a path by brute force.

Video will return here when scrolled back into view
Trump’s Tariffs Might Stick Around. What Should We Buy Now?
Trump’s Tariffs Might Stick Around. What Should We Buy Now?

Jim Brown was the second kind of running back.

Letโ€™s get this clear from the break: Whether on the field or anywhere else in life, Jim Brown doesnโ€™t dance for anybody.

Kobe Bryant dances on the court. He shimmies past defenders, glides through the air and two-steps his crossovers to leave defenders in his wake. But donโ€™t get it twistedโ€”just because Bryant moves gracefully on the court doesnโ€™t mean heโ€™s backing down from anybody.

This fight isnโ€™t a new one between Brown and Bryant. Itโ€™s an old-guard vs. new-guard slugfest that lives in the black community. Itโ€™s Jesse Jackson vs. President Obama before he got elected, and it isnโ€™t dependent on age so much as on ideology. (See Tavis Smiley vs. President Obama now.)

The crux of the problemโ€”about which all would agreeโ€”is this: The black community, especially the black male community, is in trouble. Whatโ€™s undecided is how do we get better. Run straight up the middle or dance around the sides, whatโ€™s clear is that both sides want to gain yards. Whatโ€™s at odds is more a matter of style.

Brownโ€™s statements about Kobe earlier this week werenโ€™t shocking for a man who has always taken athletes to task. On The Arsenio Hall Show, Brown made it clear that he doesnโ€™t consider Kobe to be a socially conscious black man.

โ€œHe is somewhat confused about culture, because he was brought up in another country,โ€ Brown said. (Bryant spent part of his childhood in Italy, where his father played professional basketball.) โ€œ[Bryant] doesnโ€™t quite fit whatโ€™s happening in America.โ€

Back in the 1960s, Brown hosted a gathering for top black athletes interested in social activism. โ€œIf I had to call that summit all over,โ€ he said, โ€œthere would be some athletes I wouldnโ€™t call. Kobe would be one of them.โ€

Jim Brown is old schoolโ€”from his walk to his unrelenting focus on youths in the community. He is what many black men aspired to be before heroin and prison and success came and ravaged their sense of accountability. He believes that to be a world-renowned athlete who doesnโ€™t contribute to the community or the conversation about being a better black man is to waste oneโ€™s athletic gifts. Because for Brown it is bigger than sports, and always has been.

The part that is more telling has been Bryantโ€™s reaction. Instead of privately bashing Brown for his comments, Bryant took to Twitter to further the conversation: โ€œA โ€˜Globalโ€™ African American is an inferior shade to โ€˜Americanโ€™ African Americans?? #hmm .. ,โ€ he wrote.

The question is a good one, and one that hasnโ€™t been hashed out in the African-American community: If your black experience is a global experience, does that mean you have less of a connection to the plight of the African American? If you are not a baby of the civil rights struggle, does your black experience matter?

Columnist Stephen A. Smith thinks that Brownโ€™s comments were way out of line. Smith cites the expanding community of African-American thought and says that Brownโ€™s calling out of Bryant for being different ostracizes him from a community that he belongs to by birthright. He also notes the inability of the mostly left-leaning black community to embrace black conservatives as an example of how comments like Brownโ€™s donโ€™t bring us together but actually tear us apart.

โ€œThis is a problem that exists within our community. Because you are from our community, everybody believes that everybody is supposed to be identical to one another and we canโ€™t display or exercise any kind of versatility,โ€ Smith says. โ€œItโ€™s a problem that we have to deal with. Itโ€™s an internal problem that exists, and weโ€™re going to have to handle it because if we donโ€™t, weโ€™re gonna see more Jim Browns speaking out against more Kobe Bryants, and weโ€™re gonna see more Kobe Bryants retaliating against the likes of Jim Brown.โ€

The saddest part about this argument between the old guard and the new guard is that it plays out in the public sphere and, in doing so, employs athletic-sized egos that donโ€™t bend or give in.

As of now, Bryant is interested in furthering the conversation, as he stated clearly to Smith. Itโ€™s an important one to have, but he isnโ€™t interested in sitting down with Brown. When ESPN asked Bryant if he had any interest in talking to the football great, his answer was a flat-out no:

Thereโ€™s nothing to talk about. We have different perceptions and different views on it, clearly. So the thing that Iโ€™m trying to do always, what Iโ€™ve been trying to do, is try to educate our youth going forward, no matter what color skin you areโ€”be it African American or white or whatever the case may be. Just try to talk about having a bright future and how to help kids going forward and progress as a society as a whole.

Brown and Bryant. Two giants in their sports. Two different views. Both winning in life. Meanwhile, the only losers are the young black men across the country who wonโ€™t get the opportunity to see two black men come together for the sake of a bigger prize.

Read more atย ESPN.

Straight From The Root

Sign up for our free daily newsletter.