Arlen Specter: Democrat in Training

Illustration for article titled Arlen Specter: Democrat in Training

Forget Day 100—Day 99 was far more interesting. Shortly after noon on Tuesday, Sen. Arlen Specter announced that he will campaign for reelection in 2010 as a member of the Democratic Party. News of the longtime Pennsylvania Republican’s defection sent shock waves through the Capitol and left Democrats enthused and senior Republican Party officials scrambling for an explanation.


At a press conference in the Capitol today, Specter said this decision was motivated by the strain of “extreme” conservatism that has infused the Republican Party of late. “Since my election in 1980, as part of the Reagan Big Tent, the Republican Party has moved far to the right. … I now find my political philosophy more in line with Democrats than Republicans,” he said.

“The extremes have taken over,” he said to reporters later—pointing to the example of other fallen Republican moderates of the Bush era. “Sometimes a party asks too much.”


As the fifth-oldest member of Congress, Specter may have decided it was time to look out for himself. The extended Democratic primary between Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton registered 200,000 more Democrats than Republicans in Pennsylvania and—as with the rest of the country—the remaining state Republicans were more conservative and less likely to support Specter’s liberal positions like his support of abortion rights and stem cell research. The five-term senator only just slunk into office in 2004 with 52 percent of the vote and was polling 21 points behind GOP challenger Pat Toomey last week. Specter, who said he consulted these public opinion polls before making his decision, may just have been trying to keep his seat—any seat.

Having gleefully tossed all his GOP baggage overboard, Specter goes from being a moderate, unloved Republican at risk of being primaried out of public office in 2010, to the hero of the Democratic Party.

As with prior party defections in the Senate, from Strom Thurmond in 1964 to Jim Jeffords in 2002, this changes the Capitol’s mathematics significantly. Specter is now the 59th sitting senator affiliated with the Democratic Party. (Joseph Lieberman, an Independent from Connecticut, has pledged to caucus with the Democrats.) If and when Democratic candidate Al Franken is seated as a senator from Minnesota, this will push the Democratic caucus number to 61­—a filibuster-proof majority of the size not seen since Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society.

By many accounts, the Democrats pushed hard for this victory. Specter called Democratic Majority leader Harry Reid with his decision before he called his own party leader Mitch McConnell, around 6:00 p.m. Monday night. Vice President Joe Biden, along with Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell, had pleaded with Specter to become a Democrat when visiting Philadelphia back in March. And moderate Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana greeted Specter with a full-throated “welcome” as he exited the Capitol subway this afternoon. President Obama reportedly spoke with Specter seven minutes after he heard the news, and told him Democrats are "thrilled to have you."


Suddenly, Democrats may feel an extraordinary amount of freedom to pass bills that do not require GOP support, from a plan to renovate energy policy in America, which Specter supports, to the union-supported Employee Free Choice Act, which he opposes. “It will make it more likely that the agenda that [Obama] has set forth—to get the economy moving, and focus on issues like energy and education—will now have a greater chance of moving forward,” says Democrat Bob Casey, the junior senator from Pennsylvania. “We’re happy about that.”

Ironically, 61 Democratic Senate votes could actually promote more bipartisanship. The White House had recently decided to use the budget reconciliation process to pass health care reform—setting a date before which both houses of Congress must pass a bill, which would then be subject to a simple majority vote. This was seen as an extraordinary measure that became necessary only because the Senate was consistently hijacked by minority rule and threats of filibuster. Valerie Jarrett, senior adviser to the president, speaking just before news of the defection broke, said that the White House Office of Legislative Affairs is advising the president about possibly employing budget reconciliation as a negotiating tactic relating to more than health care. But now that they have a working majority of 61 votes, the Obama administration may be able to enter its next 100 days with more cooperative Republicans and fewer egos bruised in the reconciliation process—which Specter said factored into his decision.


On the Hill, lawmaker reactions ranged from being stunned to being furious. While Sens. Casey and Reid were all smiles for the press, Specter’s move is nothing if not a crushing political blow to the Republican Party, whose prospects of thwarting the Democratic majority agenda have all but fizzled. McConnell and John Boehner, House Minority Leader, were with first lady Michelle Obama, attending a concert and unveiling of the Sojourner Truth Memorial in the Capitol Visitors’ Center when the news broke, and quickly marched out. Specter claimed to be “disappointed by some of the responses” from GOP senators at the day’s Republican caucus luncheon, but also said that his friend Sen. Thad Cochran joked “at least he wouldn’t have to go to Erie [Pa.] to campaign.”

This development also seems to let the air out of the tires of Republican moderates like Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins of Maine, who have even more liberal voting records than Specter and who had seemed to relish the power they enjoyed as persuadable members of the minority party. Snowe, seen walking alone outside of the Senate subway, said, upon word of the news: "Ultimately we are heading to having the smallest
political tent in history.”


Dayo Olopade is the Washington reporter for The Root.

Covers the White House and Washington for The Root. Follow her on Twitter.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter