Stop and Frisk, but in a Pandemic: Data Confirms Black New Yorkers Targeted for Social Distancing Violations at Higher Rates

Illustration for article titled Stop and Frisk, but in a Pandemic: Data Confirms Black New Yorkers Targeted for Social Distancing Violations at Higher Rates
Photo: John Minchillo (File AP Photo)

After a series of violent arrest videos went viral this week, the NYPD finally released citywide data on social distancing arrests on Thursday night.


“Police officers made at least 120 arrests and issued nearly 500 summonses for social-distancing violations between March 16 and May 5,” the New York Times reports. “Citywide, black people make up 68 percent of those arrested on charges of violating social-distancing rules, while Hispanic people make up 24 percent.”

As was reported earlier by WCBS, just 7 percent of those arrested for poor social distancing practices were white.

More detail on the violations was released Friday afternoon. Out of 374 social distancing summons specifically citing health code violations and Mayor Bill de Blasio’s executive order, 304 were given to black and Latinx people. The data was released by the NYPD.

The numbers appear to validate what many had suspected for weeks—that black New Yorkers were being over-policed compared to white residents. According to the most recent Census, black people comprise a quarter of the city’s population, while Hispanics and Latinx make up 27.5 percent.

Over the last few weeks, as reports of arrests suggested major discrepancies in the ways majority black and brown neighborhoods were being policed, some public officials and criminal justice advocates have likened the social-distancing arrests to “stop-and-frisk,” the unconstitutional practice of arresting mostly black and Latinx men and boys with little to no cause. The practice is most associated with the NYPD during former-Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s tenure.


De Blasio has long been a public critic of stop-and-frisk and pushed back against the comparison to the Times on Thursday.

“What happened with stop-and-frisk was a systematic, oppressive, unconstitutional strategy that created a new problem much bigger than anything it purported to solve,” he said. “This is the farthest thing from that. This is addressing a pandemic. This is addressing the fact that lives are in danger all the time. By definition, our police department needs to be a part of that because safety is what they do.”


Later, once the Times story went live, de Blasio addressed the discrepancies in arrests publicly.

“Most people practice social distancing, with only hundreds of summonses issued over 6 weeks,” the mayor wrote. “But the disparity in the numbers does NOT reflect our values.”


“We HAVE TO do better and we WILL,” he added.


The disparities in social distancing arrests garnered much public scrutiny this week after several high-profile arrests drew outrage online.

Earlier in the week, the NYPD deflected on whether race was an issue in the arrests.


“The common denominator here is starting with a lack of compliance,” said NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea, according to Gothamist. “Every incident is unique and has to be examined under the lens of the circumstances of that particular incident.”

But for others viewing the videos on social media, there was another clear common denominator: the fact that the offenders are black. The racial disparity was especially stark considering many New Yorkers took to city streets and parks last weekend. Photos taken at the parks parks showed throngs of residents—many of them white, some not wearing face masks or coverings—reveling in the warm spring weather.


Many on social media contrasted the disturbing arrest videos with images of NYPD officers handing out masks to people at city parks. In the latter pictures, all of the recipients appeared to be white.


As the Times reports, the Brooklyn District Attorney’s office was the first, and thus far, the only prosecutor in the city to release statistics on its social-distancing arrests. There, the racial discrepancies were even more pronounced than they were citywide:

In the borough, the police arrested 40 people for social-distancing violations from March 17 through May 4, the district attorney’s office said.

Of those arrested, 35 people were black, four were Hispanic and one was white.

More than a third of the arrests were made in the predominantly black neighborhood of Brownsville. No arrests were made in the more white Brooklyn neighborhood of Park Slope.


New York Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, who represents Brooklyn, also drew the comparison between the social-distancing arrests and the city’s infamous stop-and-frisk policies. With black communities already suffering disproportionately from the coronavirus itself, as well as from unemployment and hunger brought on by the pandemic, Jeffries said the added vulnerability to arrests presented “a toxic combination.”

As Jeffries told the Times, “We can’t unleash a new era of overly aggressive policing of communities of color in the name of social distancing.”

Staff writer, The Root.



An article recently came out that showed that most of the cases in the US came from New York, so is there anything else that fine city wants to fuck up? Maybe it can spread the honest to god bubonic plague while we’re at it, god only knows the city has done a bang up job with everything else. I mean New York is far from the largest city on the planet, but for some reason they can’t get their shit together.