In VP Debate, Mike Pence Goes on 90-Minute Shaggy ‘It Wasn’t Me’ Defense

Republican vice presidential nominee Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate at Longwood University in Farmville, Va., on Oct. 4, 2016.
Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Unless you’re one of those people whose Pandora/iTunes/Tidal service features no music that dropped before “Trap Queen,” you might remember a pop-reggae song called “It Wasn't Me” from one-hit wonder and Rick Fox look-alike Shaggy. The song notes Shaggy’s tale of woe as he is busted by his girlfriend for “creepin’ with the girl next door.” Despite the obvious evidence of Shaggy’s infidelity, he’s got the same answer:

She even caught me in the shower
It wasn’t me
Saw me banging on the sofa
It wasn’t me
She even caught me on camera
It wasn’t me


We all knew Mike Pence was a rapper, but who knew he dipped into reggae? Tuesday night’s vice presidential debate featured the Republican employing the Shaggy defense, denying everything that running mate Donald Trump ever said.

Democrat Tim Kaine, for his part, knew his job going into the debate. No one cares what the vice presidents think or say, and unless your name is Dan Quayle or Sarah Palin, a vice president usually can’t really help or hurt the top of the ticket. Kaine rushed into the debate like a suburban Little League coach arguing every call on behalf of his daughter. His goal was to make Pence answer for every terrible thing that Trump has ever said, and Pence just denied everything.


“Did Trump call Mexicans rapists?”

Never said it.

“Did you and Donald Trump say Vladimir Putin was a strong leader?”

Wasn’t me.

“Did Donald Trump say women who get abortions should be punished?”

Who’s Donald Trump?

I’m pretty sure that by the end of the night, Pence was denying that he was governor of Indiana or that his name was even Mike Pence. While many political pundits declared Pence the “winner” because he appeared calm and steady during the debate, he lost the overall war by providing the Hillary Clinton campaign with enough material to create an anti-Trump mixtape from his own vice presidential pick. In fact, before the debate was even over, the Clinton campaign had released a video contrasting every Pence denial with Trump saying and doing exactly what had just been denied.


Kaine may sound like a suburban youth pastor in dad jeans who hums over the curse words when he’s singing along with the radio, but he knows how to generate some viral video. His suicide pact with Clinton to damage his nice-guy brand in order to trick Pence into a supercut of the Shaggy defense worked beautifully.

How bad was it? Reports from the Trump campaign are that the top of the ticket is unhappy with Pence’s defense of his running mate. Worse, many analysts (myself included) believe that Pence was foot-dragging in defending Trump because he’s angling to be the GOP nominee in 2020 and doesn’t want to be seen as being too deep in the tank for the bombastic billionaire.


On the Clinton side, this is a victory of sorts. Kaine did his job, and now he can fade back into obscurity wandering the mall kiosks next to Orange Julius and wondering why his daughters want a bedazzled cellphone case. Clinton has first lady Michelle Obama, President Barack Obama, Vice President Joe Biden and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren to do her heavy lifting as surrogates in the campaign.

In the end, no one will remember this vice presidential debate; Clinton and Trump have such huge personalities that the town hall debate on Sunday will overshadow anything that happened at Longwood University in Farmville, Va. However, in the short term, this is another victory for the Clinton campaign because she, with help from Kaine and Pence, turned a 90-minute debate into 24 hours of negative news coverage for Trump.


Jason Johnson, political editor at The Root, is a professor of political science at Morgan State’s School of Global Journalism and Communication and is a frequent guest on MSNBC, CNN, Al-Jazeera International, Fox Business News and SiriusXM Satellite Radio. Follow him on Twitter.

Share This Story