President-elect Donald Trump has been very clear about his plans for education reform under his administration. He plans to reprioritize federal dollars for an additional federal investment of $20 billion toward school choice. This, he says, will give states the option of funding studentsโ education at the public or private school of their choice. It will also favor states that have private school choice, magnet schools and charter laws. Trump says his plan will establish the national goal of providing school choice to each of the 11 million school-age children living in poverty.
Suggested Reading
โAs your president, I will be the nationโs biggest cheerleader for school choice. I want every single inner-city child in America who is today trapped in a failing school to have the freedomโthe civil rightโto attend the school of their choice,โ Trump says. โI understand many stale, old politicians will resist. But itโs time for our country to start thinking big once again.โ
To lead that charge, the president-elect has nominated Michigan billionaire Betsy DeVos to be U.S. secretary of education. On her website, she touts her former leadership of the school-choice advocacy group American Federation for Children, describing herself as a โnational leader in the fight to boldly reform Americaโs broken education system.โ
โAs a result of AFCโs work,โ her website says, โover one million children are now in the school of their parentsโ choice, instead of being trapped by their zip code in a school that failed to meet their needs.โ
But school choice is a controversial subject, and critics have said that DeVosโ vision, which she says will bring a broad array of โchoice,โ would actually privatize the nationโs public education system. In a March 2015 speech at the SXSWedu convention in Texas, the woman who has called the traditional public education system a โdead endโ drew a stark picture of what she sees as the difference between high-performing private or charter schools and low-performing public schools. She presented a hypothetical choice between โAlpha School โฆ a high-performing school with graduation rates ranging from 70 to 90 percent,โ and a second, โlow-performingโ school โwith graduation rates hovering around 50 percent."
โIf you chose Alpha School, then, in Washington, D.C., you chose a private or charter school for your kids. If you chose Beta School, you chose the traditional public school,โ DeVos said.
DeVos has not said that she wants to eliminate public schools, and she includes them in her list of what she describes as an open system of choice. The conservative Heritage Foundation backs her nomination for education secretary, saying in a statement, โBetsy DeVos has been a staunch supporter of more education choices for students and parents, and the school choice movement will have a champion in the Education Department.โ
But the American Federation of Teachers blasted Trumpโs selection in a statement from President Randi Weingarten, who called DeVos an โanti-public-education nominee.โ
โIn nominating DeVos, Trump makes it loud and clear that his education policy will focus on privatizing, defunding and destroying public education in America,โ Weingarten said. โDeVos has no meaningful experience in the classroom or in our schools. The sum total of her involvement has been spending her familyโs wealth in an effort to dismantle public education in Michigan. Every American should be concerned that she would impose her reckless and extreme ideology on the nation.โ
There has been some criticism of DeVosโ involvement in Michigan, where she and her husband not only have contributed at least $7 million to the state party and lawmakers but also have influenced nearly every major piece of education legislation since the 1990s. The Detroit Free Press, in an editorial, blasted DeVos for supporting an โideological lobby that has zealously championed free-market education reform for decades, with little regard for the outcome.โ The editorial went on to call her a โlobbyistโ with โno relevant credentials or experience for a job setting standards and guiding dollars for the nationโs public schools.โ
Julian Vasquez Heilig, director of the doctorate in educational leadership at California State University, Sacramento and the California NAACP education chair, said at NBC News that school choice does not produce the equity, social justice or Latino-student success spun by those who support it. He said that the nation should support community-based, democratically controlled schools such as open-enrollment magnets, in-district charters and community schools with wraparound services.
โWhen corporations and churches control the schools โฆ they control opportunity and access,โ Heilig wrote. โIt is not in the best interest of childrenโespecially poor childrenโto create a system that allows corporations and churches to make those decisions about individual students.โ
But DeVos supporters such as Phil Handy, who served with her on the Foundation for Excellence in Education board of directors, say that the reason there is controversy over her appointment is that she is a โpariahโ to the education establishment and a โblessingโ to children trapped in failing schools. Handy wrote in the Dallas Morning News: โShe can be most effective, not by increasing Washingtonโs power over education but by reducing it. โฆ She has been a disruptive change agent in a public education system that for decades has failed Americaโs most disadvantaged students and perpetuated cycles of poverty.โ
Handy, a former chairman of the Florida Board of Education, cited a 2015 Stanford University study (pdf), which found that โlearning gains for charter school students are larger by significant amounts for black, Hispanic, low-income and special education students in both math and reading.โ
In a recent speech, outgoing U.S. Education Secretary John King said that he hopes both Republicans and Democrats unite behind the goal of building a strong and fair public education system. He also said that his department should continue to fight for better schools for all Americans.
โI am convinced that the growing conflicts in this country over race and religion and language would be profoundly reduced if our citizens were able to learn and play alongside classmates who were different from themselves,โ King said.
Allison Keyes is an award-winning correspondent, host and author. She can be heard on CBS Radio News, among other outlets. Keyes, a former national desk reporter for NPR, has written extensively on race, culture, politics and the arts. Follow her on Twitter.
Straight From
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.