Ariz. Trying to Ban Social-Justice Courses in State Schools. Guess Who This Targets?

Getty Images
Getty Images

Let’s start this off by reminding folks that Arizona was one of the last states in the nation to recognize the Martin Luther King Jr. national holiday (and lest we forget, Republican Sen. John McCain voted against its recognition, too).


Living up to that lovely legacy, Republican lawmakers in the state are now advocating legislation to prohibit school courses and events that promote “ethnic studies and social justice”—obviously targeting black and brown citizens of the Copper State.

The Guardian reports that the newly introduced bill, H.B. 2120, which builds on an existing GOP-backed law that banned a Mexican-American-studies class, would prohibit “courses, classes, events and activities” in public schools that promote “social justice toward a race, gender, religion, political affiliation, social class or other class of people.”

According to the Arizona Daily Star, Republican state Rep. Bob Thorpe of Flagstaff, who introduced the bill, said that the 2010 law that targeted “ethnic studies” courses at some public schools, including those in the Tucson Unified School District, does not go far enough with its prohibition against teaching anything that promotes resentment toward another race.

Thorpe reportedly wants to ban not just classes but also any events or activities that “negatively target specific nationalities or countries,” and would extend the new restrictions to community colleges and universities.

The new bill also gives the state attorney general the power to withhold up to 10 percent of state aid if he or she determines that a college or university is in violation.

This move is the latest shot in the recently revived culture wars, in which campus conservative groups and state legislators have railed against professors, groups and courses that challenge conservative views on race, gender and sexuality. State legislatures seem to be the latest battlegrounds.


“By attempting to legislate against certain types of activities that focus on people of color, women or social justice issues,” said Rashad Shabazz, head faculty in the program of justice and social inquiry at Arizona State University, “it really undermines the ability of the university to function as a space of intellectual engagement and debate.”

The Guardian reports that in Wisconsin, a Republican senator recently attacked an undergraduate program focused on “unpacking masculinity,” which the lawmaker called a “war on men.” Lawmakers there have also threatened to cut funding over a race-relations course called “The Problem of Whiteness” and a reading assignment about gay men’s sexual preferences that a legislator said was “offensive.”


The University of California, Berkeley, last year canceled a course examining Palestine “through the lens of settler colonialism” following an outcry from pro-Israel groups, but later reinstated the class.

Arizona’s 2010 law banning a specific Mexican-American-studies program in Tucson continues to be the subject of lengthy litigation.


Not Enough Day Drinking

I’m not sure if that’s as bad or worse than Texas which tried to adopt a Mexican-American studies textbook that:

drew widespread criticism for flaws and using stereotypes that suggest Mexicans were “lazy” and that Chicano activists in the 1960s were out to “destroy society.”

One state is trying to avoid the subject completely, the other is actively trying to promote stereotypes.

Sidenote: How can Mexicans be lazy and take all our jobs at the same time?