Why Is LAPD Going to Patrol City Buses and Trains When There Aren’t Enough Officers Patrolling the L.A. Streets?

Robyn Beck/Getty Images
Robyn Beck/Getty Images

Two days ago, the Los Angeles City Council’s Public Safety Committee pressed the Los Angeles Police Department for detailed explanations of how officers are deployed across city streets, amid concerns that there aren’t enough cops working patrol duty to adequately respond to calls for help.


As if to mock that concern and add insult to injury, the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority board of directors announced Thursday that the LAPD will begin patrolling trains and buses as part of a new multiagency approach to transit security beginning July 1, CBS News reports.

The timing of Metro’s announcement is ironic, considering a Los Angeles Times report earlier this week:

How the LAPD uses its roughly 9,900 officers has drawn fresh attention from City Hall in recent months, with the union representing rank-and-file cops leading the charge. Union officials have accused LAPD brass of pulling too many officers from patrol duties for specialized units, such as the recently formed Community Relationship Division and much-publicized Metropolitan Division, an elite unit that was doubled in size in 2015 to help suppress the citywide crime surge.

As a result, the police union has said, patrol officers are forced to rush from call to call, slowing response times, preventing police from building connections with residents and hurting officer morale.

Currently, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department patrols the city transit system and has had jurisdiction over it for the last five years. Metro staff say the change would put more law-enforcement personnel in buses and trains and result in faster response times.

L.A. Mayor Eric Garcetti, who serves as first vice chair on Metro’s board, supports the change and said, “The safety of our Metro passengers and employees must always be our first priority.”

While the safety of Metro passengers and employees is important and should be a priority, the safety of the citizens of the city in which Metro operates is of utmost importance, too.

Crime in Los Angeles continued to rise last year, and residents and officers alike have complained about slow response times and low police presence in some neighborhoods.


More from the Times:

Those supporting the call for more patrol officers have pointed to a figure from 1969, which was cited in the motion introduced by Bonin and Buscaino. On an average day in 1969, they said, 337 cops patrolled the city in about 180 cars. By comparison, during one afternoon in December 2016, 311 officers patrolled the city in fewer than 160 cars, according to the motion.

LAPD Assistant Chief Michel Moore cautioned council members that the department’s current deployment strategy reflected the “added complexity” of law enforcement in 2017. Today, he said, specialized units—those that address domestic violence, gang crime, mental illness and homelessness, for example—“augment and support” the cops working patrol duties.

For example, in addition to the 311 officers on patrol on the December afternoon, an additional 462 personnel were working special traffic, gang, mental health or Metro details, according to a handout from the LAPD

“The LAPD of 2017 is vastly different from the LAPD of 1969,” Moore said. “It’s a department that focuses on long-term problem-solving rather than merely responding to emergency calls and arresting people.”


But can that LAPD be spared to supervise passengers on city trains and buses?

LAPD’s contract with Metro specifies that it will patrol Metro areas within the city of Los Angeles. More than 60 percent of Metro’s buses and 5o percent of its rail lines operate within L.A. boundaries.


The contract will increase the number of law-enforcement personnel working over a 24-hour period to “a consistent 314.”

Granted, that’s a combination of the LAPD, LASD and Long Beach Police Department, but what about the city of Los Angeles?


From CBS News:

LAPD Chief Charlie Beck told the board that adding Metro to his responsibilities would not require the addition of new officers to the force but would require more overtime hours. Commanders and supervisors would work on Metro full-time, but officers on patrol will be deployed primarily though the use of overtime hours, Beck said.

He also said that no officers currently working on regular operations duties would be moved to patrol Metro.

“It is my contention that this will increase safety in Los Angeles because it puts more cops in more cars, on more buses, on more trains, that work in concert with their brothers and sisters in the stations,” Beck said.


The deal is at least lucrative for the LAPD, which will receive $369.3 million, while the LASD will receive $246.3 million and the Long Beach PD will receive $30.1 million.

That’s a lot of money to hand out fare-evasion citations.

Speaking of fare-evasion citations, it’s worth noting that according to a civil rights complaint filed by the Labor/Community Strategy Center, from 2012 to 2015, although black riders make up only 19 percent of Metro riders, they received more than 5o percent of all fare-evasion citations and made up 60 percent of all arrests on Metro.


The U.S. Department of Transportation announced in January that it was investigating the complaint.


*Thinking emoji.*

This wouldn’t be a system at play, would it?

Why stop crime or even prevent it when you can have an instant feeder system into the prison pipeline?


Fare-evasion citations are a fast and easy way to introduce everyone, young and old, into a criminal-justice system that announced Thursday it would continue to use the private prison industry.

But let’s keep pretending that these things are not related. It helps us sleep better at night.


Read more at CBS News and the Los Angeles Times.

News Editor for The Root. I said what I said. Period.


Jane Error

I trust the LAPD beat cops and the LAPD institutional leadership both so little that I had to get to the end of the story to figure out who was getting fucked over and how in this scenario.