Watch: The Root Staff Executes the Battle of the Fruitcakes 

The holidays are here, and what would the holidays be without fruitcake? Suggested Reading GloRilla Gives Update on Friendship With Young Thug Months After Viral Negative Tweets Even More Crazy Events No One Could Have Predicted in 2025 A Peek Inside The Root 100 Party’s Swag Bag Video will return here when scrolled back into…

The holidays are here, and what would the holidays be without fruitcake?

Video will return here when scrolled back into view
Ayo Edebiri, ‘OPUS’ Cast on Staying Sane in Hollywood and the Film’s Ambiguous Ending

For many, the answer would be “a time to share love with friends and family, just without a fruitcake.” Touché.

Still, here at The Root, we acknowledge that to some, fruitcake is a tradition. So The Root staff decided to put this Christmas staple to the test in “the battle of the fruitcakes.”

Here’s the deal: The Root pitted the traditional American fruitcake against the Jamaican fruitcake (which has several aliases: black cake, rum cake, rum fruitcake, fruit and rum cake, you name it). After a thorough palate cleansing followed by a gastronomic examination, we cast votes and called a winner.

Two fruitcakes. One taste test. See which cake claimed the top spot.

Felice León is multimedia editor at The Root.

Straight From The Root

Sign up for our free daily newsletter.