Upon its theatrical release, "Sinners" ignited a firestorm of discourse centered on its dense symbolism and layered clues. Now, with the film accessible via streaming platforms, a new wave of viewers has the opportunity to dissect and decipher the movie's underlying messages. For those who've yet to experience "Sinners," perhaps bookmark this for later—no peeking!
Suggested Reading
The narrative plunges us into the 1930s, an era indelibly marked by the brutal realities of Jim Crow. Let's excavate some of the film's hidden depths and nuances. Brace yourselves, this is going to be a ride. And fair warning: spoilers abound.
Remmick Falls Out Of The Sky
One of the eeriest parts of the film is Remmick’s first appearance at Bert and Joan Hoagwood’s farmhouse. Torn, tattered, and covered in dirt, he stumbles into frame like some sort of dark entity. He doesn’t just arrive — he crashes, barely catching his balance as he stands.
If you’ve ever heard of a “fallen angel,” this might be a visual metaphor at work. Remmick didn’t just show up…it appears he fell from the sky, struck down like lightning. If that's the case, he's not just dangerous — he's a demon temporarily showing up in human form. And in the end, his final reveal was wild.
The Baby In The Back Room
When the blood-obsessed Remmick appears in the home of Bert and Joan Hoagwood, he’s seen in an eerie back room sitting in a rocking chair. Not sure if viewers noticed, but there were baby accessories in that room, including a crib, baby toys, and blankets.
That said, there was no baby to be found. Did Remmick eat that baby? Many believe he was simply too bloodthirsty to pass up the opportunity, *shivers*.
The Juke Joint
Sweating, dancing, sipping — the juke joint was a symbol for Black unity, autonomy, and resistance. While the 1930’s was riddled with hardcore racism, the twins fought for the space to be seen as a refuge. It’s clear their goal was to reclaim power, joy, and some autonomy, despite the oppression surrounding them.
Nonetheless, their peace was brutally interrupted when the vampires — the only White people in the scene *suspicious eyes* — who arrived at the door asking to join the party. The hair stood up on the back of their necks and rightfully so. This gem tells us that darkness has to be invited in to ruin the party, rendering the joint a sort of spiritual threshold between good and evil.
Culture Vultures
Sammie Moore's dad, Reverend Jedediah, begged him not to pursue blues as a strict follower of the church, dishing him a warning that would later unfold with a vengeance. “You keep dancing with the devil, and one day it's gonna follow you home.”
Once Sammie started pulling the strings of the guitar given to him by Smoke and Stack, performing the song “I Lied To You,” Remmick and his vampire friends are summoned to the party by the beautiful music. While Black men and women were channeling their ancestors, it’s clear Remmick wanted to exploit that spiritual power for his own gain, which we know all too well. Culture vultures.
Mary — The Traitor
This is when things get… well, bloody. In “Sinners”, there’s a sharp line drawn between Black unity and the presence of White outsiders. But Mary — played by Hailee Steinfeld — is the only character who blurs those lines. Half-White and half-Black, she moves between worlds… and turns out to be a traitor in more ways than one.
She shows up to the party uninvited, slips out, gets bitten by Remmick, and comes back to their sanctuary. Though she spends the whole film chasing Stack’s love, she’s the one who ends him — manipulating him with intimacy. Stack had no idea the girl he ran from would be the death he ran into. In the words of Dr. Umar, “Black Queens forever — snow bunnies never!”
The Presence of the Choctaw Natives
While the Mississippi Choctaw Natives don't appear often, they brought a particular message to the homeowners of the farmhouse — watch your back. Diving deeper, this lets us know that the Natives and Black people in the film share a common enemy. From a historical perspective, enslaved Africans and Natives were known to form alliances to resist colonizers and slaveowners.
For example, the Black Seminoles were a group of Black people who escaped slavery and joined the Seminole tribe in Florida, forming a powerful alliance that resisted U.S. military efforts during the Seminole Wars in the 1830s-1840s. Although the Blacks and Natives don’t appear in the same scene, they’re aligned through rebellion.
The Easter Egg After The Credits
Long after the town has tried to forget, Stack and Mary reappear — unchanged, untouched by time. Sammie on the other hand, now a wise man who’s visibility aged, doesn’t seem alarmed. These demons are crossing generations, and now he knows what they look like when he sees them.
In another Easter egg scene, Sammie returns to his father’s church — unchanged and pure — singing “This Little Light of Mine” while playing the very same guitar he used to battle the bloodsuckers. This moment challenges the idea that his music is solely a force for evil, as his father once warned. Instead, it offers a bright, uplifting contrast, giving viewers a powerful sense of calm and reminding us of music’s pure, redemptive side.
Straight From 
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.