Let our next greatest achievement be realizing the dream of full equality for all of us ...

- Human Rights Campaign President, Alphonso David, as reported by Maiysha Kai -


NEWSWEEK: Lessons From the Failure of Artur Davis

In trying to be post-racial, says Newsweek columnist Ellis Cose, the man who might have been Alabama's first black governor ignored his base. We can't all be Barack Obama.

Artur Davis was supposed to be the Deep South's first elected black governor. He had arrived at Harvard Law School in 1990-months after Barack Obama was elected president of the law review. And many, in Alabama and elsewhere, thought his political gifts rivaled those of the president himself. "A lot of people would have liked to have seen Alabama elect its first black governor, and a lot of people thought Artur could be that person," says James Rotch, a prominent white attorney whose Birmingham Pledge Foundation seeks to foster interracial harmony. Instead, the 42-year-old congressman lost (by more than 20 points) a Democratic primary that had seemed to be his for the taking. "This is not exactly the speech I'd planned to give," he somberly admitted last Tuesday as he conceded to state Agriculture Commissioner Ron Sparks.


Davis's spectacular collapse makes abundantly clear that, even in the age of Obama, black politicians can easily wander into quicksand as they try to move beyond their traditional black base. Davis's biggest mistake, say local political observers, was to assume that blacks would rally behind him and that many liberal whites would do the same, making the primary little more than a formality. "He ran his whole race as it if were a general election and he wanted to claim some conservative street cred. Alabama Democrats-blue dots in this big red state-have very little patience for that," Birmingham News columnist John Archibald told me in an e-mail.

Jesse Lewis, publisher of The Birmingham Times, a black-oriented weekly, says most blacks in the state would have liked nothing more than to see an African-American as chief executive but couldn't warm up to a candidate who didn't seem to have their interests at heart. Many critics saw Davis's opposition to the president's health-care legislation as a blatant attempt to pander to white voters. The Rev. Jesse Jackson, among others, slammed Davis, saying he had voted against the well-being of his own constituents. "That created real tension," Jackson told me. State Sen. Hank Sanders insists that Davis dug his political grave by refusing to seek the support of the state's most powerful black political organizations. The mortified groups backed his white opponent. If Davis "wasn't going to talk to us before the election, he certainly wasn't going to talk to us after the election," says Sanders.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter