I’m Not Saying the NYPD Is Racist, I’m Just Saying That 90 Percent of Jaywalking Tickets in the Bronx Go to Black and Brown People...And Now It’s Being Investigated

Illustration for article titled I’m Not Saying the NYPD Is Racist, I’m Just Saying That 90 Percent of Jaywalking Tickets in the Bronx Go to Black and Brown People...And Now It’s Being Investigated
Image: Shutterstock

Earlier this month, Anne Branigin, The Root’s resident hot pot connoisseur, revealed some startling statistics:

A recent StreetsBlog analysis found that, between Jan. 1 and Sept. 30, 2019, NYPD issued 316 summonses for jaywalking—and nearly 90 percent went to black or Latinx people (as the article notes, this rate dwarfs the city’s black and Latinx population, which sits around 55 percent). Jaywalkers between the ages of 18 and 25 were also disproportionately targeted, receiving 44 percent of all tickets despite being just 7 percent of the population.

This is a question of which neighborhoods are being ticketed as much as it is which citizens. More than half of the summonses (164) came from police precincts in the Bronx. Despite the fact that Manhattan has the most pedestrians, police in that borough only issued 29 jaywalking summonses in that 9 month period.


And now comes the news that New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio will investigate exactly why in the hell so many black and brown folks are being disproportionately targeted for jaywalking. Because surely it can’t have anything to do with the color of their skin, right?


According to the New York Daily News, in response to Council Speaker Corey Johnson’s promise to provide a solution to this disparity, de Blasio expressed his concern with the report’s findings.

“Any time a question of disparity comes up I want to see it addressed,” he said. “And this is a nonstop effort to ensure that policing is fair across all communities.”

Nothing in America is fair across all communities, but Johnson’s approach to addressing the matter was a bit more rational.

“I’m not encouraging people jaywalking but who hasn’t jaywalked in NYC?” Johnson told reporters on Monday. “It’s crazy and the enforcement of more people of color getting the tickets—when we know more people of color are not jaywalking more than white people—shows a disproportionate level of policing in that community. We need to look at that.”

You think?

De Blasio maintains that much like alarm clocks or speed limits, tickets for jaywalking are, in fact, a necessary evil.


“We’ve got to figure out, with real challenges with busier and busier streets, how we use enforcement for everyone, the right way,” he said. “But it has to be fair. If the Council’s trying to ensure that it’s fair, I commend them, and we’ll work with them.”

No word yet on de Blasio’s plan of attack, but in the interim, if you’re black or brown you might want to wait until the light is green before crossing the street.


Or else.

Menace to supremacy. Founder of Extraordinary Ideas and co-host and producer of The Extraordinary Negroes podcast. Impatiently waiting for y'all to stop putting sugar in grits.


Raineyb1013, Misfit Black Girl Island Denizen

You’re not saying the NYPD is racist? I’ll do it for you. NYPD is racist as fuck!

I’m sure it’s merely a coincidence that in my mixed race group it was me, the other Black girl, and the Puerto Rican dude who was constantly asked to show our train pass even though we went through the same damn station every goddamn school day.

And I’m sure that Black and Latino men being stopped and frisked was a coincidence and nothing to do with NYPD’s racist ass racial profiling. I’m sure their tendency to kill Black and brown people even when unarmed while managing to take down armed and belligerent white people has nothing to do with racism.

Fuck the NYPD!