On the heels of the success of his new Prime Video series, Swarm, Donald Glover is celebrating yet another winβthis time, in connection with his 2018 hit song, βThis Is America.β
Suggested Reading
Per HypeBeast, over the weekend, a federal Manhattan judge officially dismissed the copyright infringement lawsuit filed against the rapper (who also goes by Childish Gambino) and actor back in 2021 by another rapper named Kidd Wes (legal name Emelike Nwosuocha). As previously reported by The Root at the time, the suit was brought on based off the claim that chorus and rap flow of Gambinoβs song was βunmistakably substantially similar, if not practically identicalβ to his 2016 song βMade in America.β However, U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero didnβt see it that way.
Here's HypeBeast with more:
Judge Marrero ruled that β[a] cursory comparison with the challenged composition reveals that the content of the choruses is entirely different and not substantially similar.β He also noted that the lyrics of Kidd Wes, who filed the lawsuit against Glover in 2021, were a βshort, simple, self-aggrandizing proclamationβ while βThis Is Americaβ touched on βwhat America means and how it is perceived.β
In addition, the Manhattan federal judge explained that the βflowβ of the two songs are not protected by copyrights as they βlack sufficient originalityβ while βno reasonable juryβ will agree that the lyrics are too similar in nature to be labelled as copyright infringement. Finally, Nwosuocha had failed to attain a federal copyright registration for his song, making the dismissal of the complaint warranted. βMore could be said on the ways these songs differ, but no more airtime is needed to resolve this case,β Judge Marrero wrote.
Straight From
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.