Harvard is expanding its curriculum with regard to ethnic studies. Patrick T. Brennan thinks that's foolish. Below is an excerpt of Brennan's thoughts
Suggested Reading
When the University agrees that its curriculum needs to change to address โthe growing diversity of our campusโ or any other imaginary concern of its students, it opens itself up to politically motivated efforts like ethnic studies. Tragically, worthwhile academic subjects like Egyptology have also been subsumed into the larger effort of emphasizing diversity and ascribing significance to the insignificant, as demonstrated by Professor Christopher P. Jonesโs comments that โEgypt is a major African civilization,โ and that โit is very important that Africa should be a part of what everyone thinks about the modern world.โ
Egypt is a worthwhile subject not because it is an African civilization, but because it represents an incredibly sophisticated and important ancient civilization that happens to be Africanโlet alone the fact that the Egyptians pharaohs, with the exception of 75 years of Nubian rule, were about as โAfricanโ as Ian Smith. Harvard should have an Egyptology department, or at least devote some of its resources to the study of a civilization which has had such profound influence on the world. It need not offer a course on African civilizations if there is none worthy of study. The progressive priorities of Harvardโs curriculum usually do not coincide, however, with the promotion of meaningful areas of study.
Ethnic studies is a good example of an academic subject entirely driven by a leftist political agenda. While it is not absurd to suggest that there are some worthwhile topics that fall under the heading of โethnic studies,โ the area is certainly not important enough to merit a secondary field. The Undergraduate Councilโs original proposal for the field states that it will examine โhow people of color in the United States have historically experienced social and political institutions and how, as growing populations, they will continue to encounter life in the United States.โ Americans of color have undoubtedly done some things of note, but their โencountersโ and โexperiencesโ are not of paramount importance to a university education. The ethnic studies movement is motivated by an attempt to direct more attention to a topic that deserves no more attention than it already gets, and probably a good deal less. Other similarly useless departments, like Studies of Women, Gender, and Sexuality serve similar purposesโno one would deny that Macbethโs wife is an interesting study in the construction of femininity, but such occasional instances of relevance do not justify an entire academic field.
Continue reading from the SOURCE: THE HARVARD SALIENT
Thoughts?
Straight From
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.