NYC Twins Charged With Robbing 85-Year-Old ‘Sugar Daddy’

Shalaine Foster

One 85-year-old New Yorker seeking companionship found himself in a tough situation after he was allegedly tied up and robbed by 17-year-old twins, the New York Post reports.

Paul Aronson, a widower, first met Shaina Foster on a website called Seeking Arrangement, which sets up “sugar daddies” with “sugar babies,” according to law-enforcement sources who spoke with the Post. Aronson and Shaina Foster met in person at least once before deciding to meet again Oct. 1, when Shaina invited along her twin, Shalaine Foster.


According to Shalaine’s lawyer, the three had dinner in midtown Manhattan and then went to Aronson’s high-end East 38th Street home. 

“They were lured by the attraction of a beautiful five-story townhouse,” Shalaine’s lawyer, Brian Kennedy, told the Post.

According to Kennedy, the older man began asking the twins “perverted questions” about their sexual experience, and when they tried to leave, he “grabbed one of them,” the Post reports.


The next day, about 20 hours after the incident, a friend found Aronson on the floor tied up with zip ties, with his hands behind his back and his legs tied to a coffee table, according to the police.

The twins allegedly swiped the older man’s credit cards and $500. They are being held without bail and due Monday for a court appearance. They face charges of kidnapping, robbery, assault, burglary and grand larceny. 


Read more at the New York Post.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter