2023 Emmys: These 5 Snubs Deserved More Love

The 75th annual Primetime Emmys are set to be held in September, though the potential SAG-AFTRA Actor’s strike could postpone that.

Image: STARZ

On Wednesday, nominees for the 75th annual Primetime Emmys were revealed.

Video will return here when scrolled back into view
Real Photos of Slaves Released After 15-Year Legal Battle with Harvard

Announced by Emmy-nominee Yvette Nicole Brown and Television Academy Chairman Frank Scherma, some of favorite shows and actors found out the great news of their nomination such as Abbott Elementary and its crew (namely Quinta Brunson, Janelle James, Tyler James Williams and Sheryl Lee Ralph), Dominique Fishback for Swarm, and more.

However, there were some shows and actors that didn’t make the cut in the main acting categories and some that deserved a little bit more love. So because of that, we thought we’d remind the Television Academy of some of the goodness they missed out on. Starting with…

P-Valley

Photo: STARZ

Although STARZ critically acclaimed drama P-Valley received a nomination for Outstanding Contemporary Hairstyling (which is well deserved bc Uncle Clifford’s hair is always LAID), one of the most glaring snubs when it came to the acting category is the exclusion of J. Alphonse Nicholson.

Since season one, his performance has been lauded by viewers online and critics who praise Nicholson for his emotional layering and nuanced portrayal of Chucalissa rapper Lil Murda, who—among many things—is trying to come to grips with his sexuality and relationship with the Black queer femme owner of the Pynk Uncle Clifford (played by Nicco Annan).

In fact, both Nicholson, Annan, and fellow actresses Brandee Evans, Shannon Thornton, and even newcomer (and former Snowfall star) Gail Bean were all left out of the acting categories which feels like such a big miss for a show that not only pushes boundaries, but expands conversations and continually increases in viewership.

Shortly after nominees were announced on Wednesday, Nicholson took to Twitter to thank viewers despite his snub: “Thank you for all the love. Although I didn’t get an #Emmy nomination I’m grateful to be on a series that has a huge impact on the culture. Congratulations to all the nominees. Special shout out to @PValleySTARZ hair department on their nomination.”

Snowfall

Photo: FX

This show should come as no surprise as its absence from the Emmys scene seemed to be a running theme year after year. But still, it doesn’t make the blow any less severe. Like the five seasons before it, many critics and viewers continued to revere lead actor Damson Idris’ role as Franklin Saint. And while the sixth and final season’s ending drew mixed reactions, there’s no denying the sheer star power of Idris and the supporting cast which includes Isaiah John, Amin Joseph, Angela Lewis, Gail Bean, Michael Hyatt, Devyn Tyler and more.

Bel-Air

Photo: Peacock

While some may argue that the first season of Bel-Air was better than this last one, what can’t be argued is the outstanding performances given by Olly Sholotan (a.k.a. Carlton) and Adrian Holmes (a.k.a. the “new Uncle Phil). While the series may be focused on Jabari Banks’ charismatic and magnetic Will, the aforementioned performers consistently bring their A-game to the series, adding depth, range and a necessary weighty tone that helps keep pace for the dramatically reimagined series.

Queen Charlotte

Image: Liam Daniel/Netflix

There was no way you were on the internet earlier this spring without seeing your timelines bombarded with Queen Charlotte scenes, spoilers, and stills. And that was for good reason. Even though the Shondaland series walked away with three nominations (Outstanding Period Costumes, Outstanding Period Hairstyling, and Outstanding Character Voice-Over Performance), there was no acting recognition for series leads India Ria Amarteifio or Arsema Thomas. This is surprising, to say the least, considering how both of their performances as young Queen Charlotte and young Lady Danbury, respectively were regularly applauded.

The Best Man: The Final Chapters

Photo: Peacock

Now sure, this one may be on this list in large part because of nostalgia and how swift it took over timelines once it aired—but let’s not act like there weren’t several scenes over the course of this series that deserved at least some recognition. At the very least, Regina Hall, Terence Howard and Taye Diggs’ portrayals as Candace, Quentin and Harper, respectively, were some of the best on the show. Additionally, the way they were all able to return back to characters we loved so much and pick them up like we never left should be a testament to their skills.

Straight From The Root

Sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Latest from The Root

Unveiling the New  Black Billionaires: Dr. Dre, Jay-Z and More

Unveiling the New Black Billionaires: Dr. Dre, Jay-Z and More

Dr. Dre has now joined the list of Black billionaires, per a new report from Forbes. So let’s take a look at other Black stars and influential folks who’ve amassed truly insane levels of wealth! …
Black Directors Who Should Have Oscars, But Don't

Black Directors Who Should Have Oscars, But Don’t

As Ryan Coogler could make history at the 2026 Oscars, let’s look back at Black directors whose films deserved more recognition than they got! …
Professor On Jalen Rose Saying NBA Has a 'Residue or Slavery'

Professor On Jalen Rose Saying NBA Has a ‘Residue or Slavery’

The outrage over his slavery comment misses the deeper issue of who controls the wealth created by Black athletes …
Ex-NFL Star Asked ChatGPT for Advice After Allegedly Doing the Unthinkable to His Fiancée

Ex-NFL Star Asked ChatGPT for Advice After Allegedly Doing the Unthinkable to His Fiancée

Prosecutors say ex-NFL star Darron Lee used an unconventional method to try to cover up his fiancée’s “especially heinous” murder last month …
Why There's Drama Between Janet Jackson and the New Michael Jackson Movie

Why There’s Drama Between Janet Jackson and the New Michael Jackson Movie

As fans eagerly anticipate the new Michael Jackson biopic, there’s seemingly some trouble brewing between his family over the film. Here’s what we know …
The Target Boycott Is Over, but the Fight Isn't: Leaders Reveal Progress and Work Ahead

The Target Boycott Is Over, but the Fight Isn’t: Leaders Reveal Progress and Work Ahead

The Root spoke exclusively with Pastor Jamal Bryant, Tamika Mallory and Nina Turner about how the Black community held a major corporation accountable …
After 12-year-old Girl Dies Following School Bus Fight, Her family Is Searching for Answers

After 12-year-old Girl Dies Following School Bus Fight, Her family Is Searching for Answers

Jada West reportedly experienced bullying before a fight with another girl led to her untimely death …
Shonda Rhimes Just Revealed the Tragic Event That Inspired ‘Grey’s Anatomy’

Shonda Rhimes Just Revealed the Tragic Event That Inspired ‘Grey’s Anatomy’

‘Grey’s Anatomy’ may be beloved and invoke positive feelings, but the show itself was inspired by an extremely tragic incident …
Black Americans Respond to Possible Boots on the Ground as Iran Conflict Rages Forward

Black Americans Respond to Possible Boots on the Ground as Iran Conflict Rages Forward

Black folks woke up on the last day of Black History Month to military strikes in Iran. Now, they’re voicing frustrations as questions about ground troops arise …
Former Black Inmate Makes History as First Ever in U.S. to Buy a Prison Facility

Former Black Inmate Makes History as First Ever in U.S. to Buy a Prison Facility

Kerwin Pittman becomes the first formerly incarcerated Black man to buy a U.S. prison, transforming a site of confinement into a reentry campus …
Full Timeline of Dwight Howard and Amy Luciani's Rocky 14-Month Marriage Now Headed to Divorce

Full Timeline of Dwight Howard and Amy Luciani’s Rocky 14-Month Marriage Now Headed to Divorce

Folks online who followed Dwight Howard and Amy Luciani’s marriage say its been rocky early on before Howard filed for divorce. Here’s the full rundown …
NBA Shuts Down Atlanta Hawks' 'Magic City Monday' Promotion, Black Twitter Responds

NBA Shuts Down Atlanta Hawks’ ‘Magic City Monday’ Promotion, Black Twitter Responds

The NBA canceled the Atlanta Hawks’ collab with the popular strip club after growing backlash …
Lil Baby is Trying to Save His Atlanta Neighborhood, One Property at a Time

Lil Baby is Trying to Save His Atlanta Neighborhood, One Property at a Time

After gentrification pushed thousands of Black folks out of historic Atlanta neighborhoods, rapper Lil Baby returns to his stomping grounds with a new business plan …
Smoothie King Fired Staff Who Refused MAGA Couple Service— But Here’s the Ironic Double Standard Everyone is Missing

Smoothie King Fired Staff Who Refused MAGA Couple Service— But Here’s the Ironic Double Standard Everyone is Missing

Two Michigan Smoothie King workers were canned after refusing service to pro-Trump customers, meanwhile, Black folks are calling out a double standard …
Howard University Athletes Take a Stand Against New Kneeling Policy for the National Anthem

Howard University Athletes Take a Stand Against New Kneeling Policy for the National Anthem

Since 2020, athletes at Howard University have kneeled to protest the national anthem. Now, a new policy banning kneeling is causing trouble …
Why The New Yorker's Drawing of Wunmi Mosaku Has Fans Furious 

Why The New Yorker’s Drawing of Wunmi Mosaku Has Fans Furious 

‘Sinners’ star Wunmi Mosaku has been riding high off her first Oscar nomination, but one drawing didn’t reflect that and fans are calling it out! …
Locksmith Refuses Service to Black Chick-fil-A Owner – Then Gets Hit With a Reality Check

Locksmith Refuses Service to Black Chick-fil-A Owner – Then Gets Hit With a Reality Check

A Black Chick-fil-A franchise owner went viral after recalling how a locksmith refused to help her because he didn’t believe she was the owner …
How One Black Woman is Saying No to Work and Yes to Unapologetic Rest

How One Black Woman is Saying No to Work and Yes to Unapologetic Rest

After being laid off in 2025, Brandy Walker is launching a one-year sabbatical for all Black women to join! …
You Won't Believe Why Stephen A. Smith Is Not Running For President in 2028

You Won’t Believe Why Stephen A. Smith Is Not Running For President in 2028

The host of ESPN’s “First Take” has been open about possibly running for the highest office in the nation …
Terrence Howard Just Said The Quiet Part Out Loud About Black Boys and Sexual Abuse

Terrence Howard Just Said The Quiet Part Out Loud About Black Boys and Sexual Abuse

Terrence Howard’s painful story exposes a truth we rarely confront. Black boys are vulnerable to abuse but are almost never treated like victims …