Why Shelby Steele Is Right

To get elected, Barack Obama had to downplay the importance of race. But should black Americans buy into that deal?

  • | Posted: June 30, 2009 at 6:30 AM
Alex Wong/Getty Images

I can’t believe I am writing this. But I am. Shelby Steele is right. Not in the conclusions expressed in his recent article in the Wall Street Journal about Judge Sonia Sotomayor and what her nomination reveals about President Obama’s supposed contradictions. That is the stuff of fantasy.

But Steele is right about one thing: That to win the White House, Obama and his surrogates had to downplay the significance of his race in order to garner the support of fellow white citizens while subtly appealing to traditional forms of black identity politics. 

Obama’s presidency has led some to believe that we have turned a corner in matters of race; Steele sees only a sophisticated calibration. For him, Obama’s nomination of Sotomayor betrays the lie that much has changed in the nation: He, like us, remains “a captive of America’s ongoing racial neurosis.”

We need not accept Steele’s conservatism to embrace the insight. Race matters abound. Many find it difficult to talk about them and find it even more difficult to generate policy to respond to the nettlesome racial problems that continue to confound the nation. What we are witnessing, even as we revel in the historic significance of Obama’s presidency, is a deepening of our national pathology—a scandalous silence about the various ways racism continues to impact the lives of many of our fellow citizens—as some seek to “get shut,” as Ralph Ellison would say, of blackness. When, for example, conservative opponents of Sotomayor derisively speak of her nomination as the latest instance of bad identity politics, they in effect proclaim that race and gender do not substantively matter in our public deliberations.

Of course they do. We all come from somewhere and are shaped by the traditions and historical events that inform our beliefs and actions. To deny this is to deny a crucial dimension of who we are. But conservative critics often take cover behind the very fact of Obama’s presidency—a fact which implies, at least for some, that America has put aside old racial antagonisms and that any gesture, word or deed which suggests otherwise must be soundly rejected. The price of Obama’s election, a price he indeed paid, is that race can no longer be so easily, as if it ever was, invoked in public conversation about national policy. I say this not to deny the significance of gender and class. Hillary Clinton would have faced similar problems around gender inequality if she would have won. And no politician, these days at least, can talk seriously in public about the poor; poor people, no matter their color, are simply out of bounds.

  • Comments

  • 16 Comments

This article is very interesting. Thank you very much for sharing .

inchirieri auto | fier forjat | cadouri

Of course they do. online games

Unless you're going by the racist, "one drop of black blood," Obama is half white. His mother is white, his dad African = African American, but not black.

Not all African Americans specifically need help. Human beings who have suffered over the past eight years, watching their net worth, family income go down, losing their homes -- pain, despair and needy folk come in all colors.

I checked, Obama is indeed a black man. Whether or not he played down his "race" in his bid for the White House, the fact remains that he was a negro plain for all to see when he ran.

And you've got to give white folks credit for actually voting in a black man, y'all. Do you really think they did not know he had a dark skin?

The question is what will President Obama do to help the African-American. And I'm gonna give the brother some time.

Obama is only one (half-black) man. If his campaign was based on helping poor blacks, he would have never been elected. If his campaign was based on helping gays, he would have never been elected -- fill in the blank. The same for McCain with regard to special interests. I think Obama sincerely wishes to help the NEEDY, which does NOT synonymous with BLACKS.

He has helped my family by enabling us to afford COBRA after my husband was laid off. He is now employed, I am self-employed and we gratefully pay our now affordable COBRA every month. I am black, but I am not whining about how he is not helping blacks. I like the way he doesn't concentrate on race, but instead concentrates on helping people as a whole.

Sometimes, we need to look to the churches, to OURSELVES and to charitable organizations to assist those in need. One man has only so much power to pass laws that would "help blacks." It's not like congress and the House are all black or even half black.

For now, I am in wait and see mode. I listen to, but ignore all the armchair presidents, complaining about everything that he does, as I realize he is just a man, and one man, even a patient, intelligent, down to earth half-black one can't do it all.

I am not an American but having been influenced by your culture for decades I feel qualified to respond so I will.

As far as I can tell Obama as the captain is intelligent enough to maneuver the rough waters of the most complex culture in the world. A melting pot of such magnitude deserves a leader who represents everyone without bias. Like a good judge cannot sit on a fence but must be able to make tough and fair decisions when interpreting the law. So a good president must be the same in implementing policies concerning his nation. Obama is doing a good job so far.

Racists are like any other special interest group and will always exist, You have to expect that. The cold hearted self proclaimed patriots job is to cause mischief and spread hate. When issues of race seem to die down and little white boys get teary eyed and feel like holding little Black boy's hand their job is to insure that it doesn't happen. The disease of racism needs to be part of every public school's curriculum. But I guess that will never happen since public education is heading in the direction of privatization.

Black people are an integral part of American society whether they like it of not. America could never hope to exist if anyone ever tried to remove them. In fact Black people are entwined in every aspect of it. Maybe not to the degree that they should be in some fields.

Blacks however have always been that special special interest group with the history of getting used and abused. Is Black America oblivious to Obama? I would say no. I think the force of the river on his level is unimaginably strong and it would be naive to assume that he could throw a life buoy to help Blacks out of the drowning dilemmas that they are in. I think he is turning the boat in your direction though.

America, wake up! Have you forgotten that Barack Obama is 50% white? Do you think that America has changed to the point that the people of this nation would have elected a man that was 100% Black? Not on your life! Love it, or leave it, this is still AMERICA. If Black Americans-I don't use African-Americans because most of us wouldn't step foot on the Dark Continent-like I was saying if Black Americans think for one second that Barack Obama is going to save us we're wrong. Did the bailout of the banks help us, No! How many of us got bonuses from CitiBank and AIG? Will green jobs help us, NO! How many houses in Bed-Stuy and Roxbury will be converted so that they can benefit from the green energy program? But alot of houses in Lexington and Long Island will be refitted, you can bet on that. I met Mr. Obama when he was campaigning in Iowa in the summer of '07. The crowd was 98.2% white and when I asked him what he planned to do to help the Blacks in the inner-city-the people who need help the most-he gave me a look that sent chills down my spine. When I saw the way he pandered to the white audience I knew, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that I was looking at the future President of the United States of America. Can we fault him for that? NO! He was only doing what all the other politicians do, "Get elected by any means necessary". So what if you have to sell your people out? Like fools, we voted for him anyway. But, realistically, what choice did we have? On the one hand we had a scheming, conniving Black man-or half Black man-and on the other hand we had a broke down, racist White man? That's like choosing whether you want to be stabbed to death or shot. The experience I had on that sunny day in Iowa inspired me to write my play, "Oh, the LIES we've told", so that, at least, I could make a few people laugh about the dire situation we, BLACK AMERICANS, find ourselves in. The play will be showcased in Ft. Myers, Fl. in late July '09 and on the 'net shortly thereafter. Check it out if you need a good chuckle. Laugh and keep it movin''-it's the only thing that will keep us sane. And, oh, by the way, we have only ourselves to blame; we should've voted for Al Sharpton. We know where he stands, or, at least we think we do! Peace, louJ

Why everyone who is not happy that we elected the first African American president insist that he did not play race? They obviously are furious he did not since they thought that would arouse people to the fact that he is black. Make it clear that the reason President Obama did not raise the subject is that "it doesn't matter". I'm a mixture of Portuguese, Brazilian, Belgium and African races. I do not feel I'm neither of these races, I get offended if people make jokes about white, spanish and blacks. All in my heritage. I accept all races as they are. That is a "mutt" behavior. President Obama has all races in his background. He cannot side with any race, he will side with all and fight for common good. In his mind it is not about race and all about 'good will". Get it! You all that insist to define us all as "black" or "white" or Spanish or otherwise you are out of luck with people like him and me! Get a grip!!!

Although I think your comments strayed a bit from the article I have to agree that you do bring up a good point. Right now politicians, both black and white mainly care about winning the "Hispanic" vote, which as you correctly referred to is actually the Mexican vote...(the overwhelming majority of illegal immigrants) Obama does not have to win over the black voter or community for that matter. He has that in the bag by just being black. As a Latina myself, It burns me that the average American thinks all Latinos are in favor of amnesty and increased rights for Illegals and their children born here. We do not all share in that experience. Many of us came here the legal way, learned to speak English and never collected a dime in welfare or government assistance!!! It's sad that now because of the sheer number of illegals and their offspring in this country that Obama is now going to have to pander to them...