Where’s the Beef in Africa?

Hillary Clinton’s tiff with a Congolese student obscures the real American mission in Africa: economic development.

  • | Posted: August 17, 2009 at 6:36 AM
GLENNA GORDON/AFP/Getty Images

On Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton’s recent visit to the Democratic Republic of the Congo—part of a seven-nation tour of sub-Saharan Africa—a flurry of attention focused on her sharp reply to a local student who seemed to question her role as chief diplomat of the United States. All the attention overshadowed the substance of the student’s question, which concerned mining contracts between China and Congo. It was another missed opportunity to discuss the one issue that could really make a difference in Congo and the other failing states of Africa: foreign direct investment and private-sector economic development.

Just weeks after President Barack Obama’s brief stop in Accra, Ghana, Clinton’s 10-day jaunt echoed similar themes but was by far the more hands-on experience. In South Africa and in Kenya, she emphasized the dynamic economies of each country, pushing for more and better growth. In Somalia, she met with President Sheik Sharif Sheik Ahmed, an embattled but critical ally in fighting terrorism in the Horn of Africa. In Nigeria and Liberia, she stressed good governance, the democratic process and the rule of law: “I think the people of Liberia should continue to speak out against corruption,” she said at her meeting with Liberian head of state Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, adding: “The United States officially supports what this government is doing.”

Yet for all of the bold statements and fluency with local issues that Clinton and her entourage brought to Africa, the trip looked a lot like jaunts previously taken by other U.S. diplomats. Visiting health clinics and housing projects as well as the national assemblies of her host nations, Clinton assumed the mantle of humanitarian-in-chief.

There’s no doubt that Clinton brings passion and eloquence to this role. During her visit to the Congo, she placed particular emphasis on the prevention of sexual violence in the country. With forceful language, she decried the use of rape as a war tactic: “People need to be not only ashamed if they commit rape and other sexual violence, but they need to be arrested and prosecuted and punished so that it serves as a strong message that this will not be tolerated.”

The secretary of state has been an outspoken advocate for women’s rights since her time as first lady. And the Congolese example fairly cries out for intervention. UNICEF estimates that hundreds of thousands of Congolese women and girls have been raped since 1994—more than 1,000 victims per month. Adam Hochschild, author of the indispensible King Leopold’s Ghost, recently noted that the tradition of violence stretches back to the days of Leopold’s depraved, monarchic rule:

His private army of black conscript soldiers under white officers would march into a village and hold the women hostage, to force the men to go into the rain forest for weeks at a time to harvest lucrative wild rubber. "The women taken during the last raid ... are causing me no end of trouble," a Belgian officer named Georges Bricusse wrote in his diary on November 22, 1895. "All the soldiers want one. The sentries who are supposed to watch them unchain the prettiest ones and rape them.”

In the Congo, Clinton announced a $17 million plan to fight military violence against women, specifically promoting better documentation of rapes and the training of female police officers and doctors.

The programs will help. But the real focus, says John Prendergast, co-founder of the Enough Project and a tireless advocate against the violent conflict in eastern Congo, “should be on the fuel that drives the violence: the contest over the conflict minerals extracted from the eastern war zone and helping to power our electronics industry.” As Maurice Carney, executive director of the nonprofit Friends of the Congo, says, “The violence against women is inextricably linked to the conflict in the Congo, the root cause of which is the scramble for those resources.”

It’s not just that solving the nation’s dreadful economic situation may make soldiers less likely to pillage and rape. As Clinton pointed out, economic security has been historically linked to social stability and the advancement of women. (A pioneering Namibian project is tracking how "basic income" improves social outcomes.) But by constantly seeing humanitarian crises and thus military and aid-based solutions, the U.S. obscures the more important goal for any Western policy in Africa: creating sustainable trade and economic opportunity.

  • Comments

  • 51 Comments

This article is very interesting. Thank you very much for sharing .

inchirieri auto | fier forjat | cadouri

Clinton assumed the mantle of humanitarian-in-chief. free games

The next obstacle is connected to fiances free russian dating site. Amid the Americans, who want to marry to Russian women, are a lot of divorced men in the age about 40 years -these are people who didn't cope to grow to be eventually house holders bride dating russian. In previous years, American and Russian newspapers persist in publishing harrowing facts russian dating site about Russian ladies (as well as the Ukrainian women and other residents of republics of former Soviet Union), who, softly saying, have not been that lucky in such wedlocks. Someone is Russian girls site beaten by his spouse, other is deprived of being with her kid, and somebody is even murdered, and the corpse is digged in the forest agencies russian dating. The agencies normally don't inform customers who want to tie a knot with a foreigner about the awful background of Russian girls galleries - since it is not advantageous. In Washington State, for instance, recently has been passed the law, under which the marriage agencies are forced to inform the probable brides in their mother language dating single russian that they have a right to ask an official document regarding the availability of convictions and preceding marriages with the outlanders from their fianc? S especially, for the reason of the criminal events, committed against the brides - emigrants, dating russian bride which happen more often.
Second essential problem that girls russian dating com may run into by going to another country is surely - relationship with their future spouses. According to the data russian women dating service great amount of the guys, wishing to marry Russian women are over forty years and still incapable to buy a house or to succeed in life single russian women. They predominantly consider that the women from such economically poor state will not have great requirements and therefore will be ideal for the marriage. Shocking is the fact that more and more criminal cases, which happen in America, dating russian girls as well as in other states are connected with the abuse of the foreign brides. Part dating russian bride of them are beaten or even murdered. Such cases about unsuccessful wedlock become often printed in the newspapers in foreign countries, like America, and in russian dating services. Lately, Washington, D. C accepted a law, in compliance with which russian dating bride are obliged to inform possible foreign girls of the former convictions or failed experiences with outland wives of the man, whom the russian women dating single russian is about to wed. This is done, as the measure of avoidance of the criminal cases, occurred with such scaring frequency.

I never buy from discount louis vuitton, the price is expensive and I always bought online.

Hi, everybody here, I just spent more than 1000 USD in louie vuitton and bought one gift for my wife, I think it’s worth and the bag drives my wife crazy.

Anybody knows the numbers of louis vuitton outlet in CA, I need to call them and get my bag repaired

louis vuitton outlet
Anyone know louis vuitton near by? I am looking for one but never get.

I just bought this bag from louis vuitton online shop which located in New York city, it’s wonderful.

louis vuitton sale are located in all major cities such as Shanghai, New York, etc, you may travel to these cities and get one for yourself.

If you look at the Euro/American white man's history, economic development came FIRST before social improvements. That they would expect that development would work in the opposite way for black people is pretty weird to me. They want to sit on their high horses giving lectures and putting conditions on empowering black people after they have raped the lands resources for years. Pretty racist if you ask me.

China and others have exposed them for the racist and hypocrites that they are, so they have no choice but to make future financial situations a little more attractive. I think Hilary's foreign policy has its roots in the civil rights era and the black experience here in the US. They want total subordination to the white man and total adoption of the white mans belief system before they give a few negro's anything. And Obama is going along with this.

Good article!

Aid/Loan transfers from the white man are an obstruction to development in Africa rather than a lubricator because they set the wrong incentives, foster corruption and subsidise and perpetuate underdevelopment. instead of relying on development assistance from the white man, African countries should finance their own development through the mobilisation of their own domestic resources, generating tax revenues from citizens and from extractive industries, as well as through the tapping of national and international capital markets.

I would like to read more from you about what's going on with Brazil. The white man doesn't seem to happy about some of the economic moves Brazil has been making lately. Thanx...