Print
Email
Why the right is wrong about Obama and Afghanistan.
To hear conservative critics tell it, the United States had everything in Afghanistan under control until President Barack Obama took office and messed with George W. Bush’s ingenious combination of open-ended warfare and diplomacy-by-silent treatment.
Unchastened by the hasty run-up to the Iraq War, for a solid month, an assortment of foreign-policy players has tried to hector Obama into announcing a decision on the way forward in Afghanistan. Commanding General Stanley McChrystal suggested that anything less than approval of his request for 40,000 troops was “shortsighted.” Sen. John McCain told CNN that Obama has no room to mold his strategy because “the great danger now is a half-measure” trying “to please all ends of the political spectrum.”
Now, Dick Cheney—who played a central role in deciding to break off the military’s hot pursuit of Osama bin Laden in 2003—has accused Obama of “dithering” on Afghanistan.
But Obama’s no dove. The same people on the right who supported George W. Bush’s failed prosecution of the first seven years of the war is now prejudging Obama’s war policy based on a set of faulty assumptions:
Obama wants out of Afghanistan.
Wrong. Obama is the only Western leader who can simultaneously wage war in and negotiate peace with the broader Muslim world.
Take away Obama’s parallel-track diplomatic outreach and the war—regardless of strategy—reverts back to being seen, by many in the Middle East and Central Asia (and Europe), as a dubious exercise in killing Muslims. Long-term U.S. national security interests aren’t served by this perception. Obama knows it and his critics should, too.
Obama staked his presidential campaign on the imperative of pursuing al-Qaida into the Af-Pak border region. Two months into his presidency, he ordered in 21,000 more troops.
When he came out publicly against the Iraq War in 2002, Obama went out of his way to draw this comparison: “I don’t oppose all wars ... What I am opposed to is a dumb war.”
Accepting his Nobel Peace Prize, he called himself a commander-in-chief confronting “a ruthless adversary that directly threatens the American people and our allies.”
Until he says otherwise, assume Obama still thinks of Afghanistan as the un-dumb war.
Obama has to follow the generals.
Wrong. They have to follow him. Bush set a dangerous precedent during his presidency by repeatedly leaning on “commanders on the ground” as a crutch to justify his war aims.
He left Obama an extra-constitutional legacy whereby generals—practically the inventors of “chain of command”—have to be coaxed into following orders. The time for a general to voice his preferences isn’t out in public. It’s directly in the president’s ear, in front of a congressional committee or as a retired on-air analyst at a cable news network.
But the big problem with McChrystal’s view isn’t his outspokenness about it. It’s that it doesn’t come with a time machine. Beefing up force structure and implementing a full-fledged counterinsurgency operation would clearly be the right solution—in 2002.
There’s nothing wrong per se with McChrystal’s plan. But he’s tasked with “winning” while Obama is tasked with running the world. Eight years and 807 American lives into the war, White House opponents are quick to underscore the need to add more troops, yet not as quick to add that the plan calls for committing to Afghanistan for another decade.
Obama can’t make up his mind.
Wrong. The debates going on now at the White House, in the media and among the public look unfamiliar, because they’re the debates we didn’t have when the Afghanistan war (and the Iraq war) started. Try to imagine this exchange taking place in March 2003:
Vice President Joe Biden’s preference for a pared-down counterterrorism plan is aired while other White House advisers advocate a more robust strategy. To their credit, it’s not obvious what Secretary of Defense Robert Gates or National Security Adviser James Jones favor. No doubt, though, they’ve weighed in—and kept their opinions private.
This is what a real war council should look like. Cheney’s tendency to talk tough—not letting thinking get in the way of kicking ass—is how we got here in the first place.
This month saw eight U.S. soldiers killed and 27 wounded in less than two hours of fighting in Nuristan while they prepared to withdraw from their position, a bombing of the Indian embassy in Kabul, and a Talibani preemptive strike against Pakistani Army headquarters. The Afghanistan conflict appears more critical than ever—all the more reason that Obama’s long-term national security decisions shouldn’t be made in haste.
Even as NATO announces its backing for McChrystal’s counterinsurgency program, Obama has make his decision knowing that the war’s cost will be borne primarily by Americans (and Afghanis), not Europeans.
Obama’s opponents have worn out the washed-up 2008 campaign meme—“Obama is ‘untested,’ Obama is ‘naïve’”—when it comes to matters of war and peace, but the charge holds very little weight considering that prosecution of the war from 2001-2008 mostly yielded the situation as it is today.
Taunts about indecision didn’t rattle Obama when he campaigned, and didn’t deter him from sending in more troops in March. So why do critics think they will sway him now?
Portraying Obama’s circumspect deliberation on Afghanistan—Obama’s conservatism—as a weakness won’t scare the president into acquiescence on ratcheting up troop levels. Instead, the manufactured pressure is actually giving Obama a reason to “do Obama:” Strike a middle course, continue fighting and eventually start looking for the way out.
David Swerdlick is a regular contributor to The Root. Follow him on Twitter.
Comments
Christmas is around the corner: And old customers can also enjoy the gifts sent by my company in a can also request to our company. Gifts lot,Buy more get the more。Only this site have this treatment
Our goal is "Best quality, Best reputation , Best services". Your satisfaction is our main pursue. You can find the best products from us, meeting your different needs.
http://www.dudemalls.com
New to Hong Kong : Winter Dress
---**** NHL Jersey Woman $ 40 ---**** NFL Jersey $ 35
---**** NBA Jersey $ 34 ---**** MLB Jersey $ 35
---**** Jordan Six Ring_m $36 ---**** Air Yeezy_m $ 45
---**** T-Shirt_m $ 25 ---**** Jacket_m $ 36
---**** Hoody_m $ 50 ---**** Manicure Set $ 20
HOT SELL Product Brand is below:
Nike Air Jordan(1-25)/Jordan Six Ring/Jordan Fusion/Nike Shox/Air Max/AF1/Dunk: $32
Polo/Ed Hardy/Lacoste/Ca/A&F ……T-shirt:
Coach /Gucci/Lv/Ed Hardy/D&G/Fendi ……Handbag:$35
Christian Louboutin/Lv/Ed Hardy/Gucci/Coach/Lacoste/ Timbland……
True Religion/Coogi/Evisu/Ed Hardy/Prada ……Jeans:$30
New era/Gucci/Ed hardy ……cap : $13
Okely/Coach/D&G/Fendi/Gucci/Armani ……sunglass:$15
Nike shoes: 32$, True Religion jeans:30$, Ed Hardy, t-shirts:12$, NFL Jersey:20$,Boots UGG:50$
Welcome to Shopping →→→ http://www.dudemalls.com
I wish you a happy shopping
handbags wholesale
replica handbags
Handbags Designer
handbags knockoffs
2009 Handbags
Handbags
Handbags Sale
Unique Handbags
Fake Handbags
China Handbags
True Religion Jeans
GHD Hair Straighteners
UGG Boots Shoes
Gucci Jewelry
Tiffany & Co Jewelry
منتديات صدفة
الاسلامي
الصوتيات والمرئيات الإسلامية
القسم العام
الحوار العام
الترحيب والتعارف
أخبار عامه وجرائم واثارة
همس القوافي
الخواطر والنثر
القصص والروايات
منتديات صدفة - صدفة - صدفه
English Forum
المدارس والجامعات
الاسرة والطفل
عالم المرأة والأناقة
الموضة والأزياء
المكياج والعناية بشعر
العروس ومستلزماتها
أهداف الدوري السعودي
أهداف الدوريات والبطولات العالمية
اخبار الشركات (stc - mobily - zain )
دروس التصميم
العاب Playstation 3
العاب Xbox360
العاب PC
العاب psp
عالم الرجل
الديكور والاثاث
عالم حواء للطبخ
الصحة والطب
هوليوود و بوليوود
مسلسلات كوري و ياباني
مشاهير العرب
المسلسلات التركيه
يارا الفني
الانمي وافلام الكرتون
الرياضه العالميه والعربيه
الدوري السعودي
السيارات و المحركات
مكتبة الأهداف
برامج كمبيوتر
الجوال والبلوتوث
التصميم والإبداع
دورة صدفه لتعليم الفوتوشوب
ماسنجر توبيكات رموز صور مسنجر
الالعاب الالكترونية
الألعاب والمسابقات.
فله وناسه
السياحة والسفر
عجائب وغرائب الصور
عالم بنت
منتديات عالم بنت
فعاليات و مسابقات عالم بنت
قسم العالم العام
ناقش وشارك [لا
للنقل]
أخوه في الاسلام
أهلا بمن حل ضيفا علينا
سكرابز
سكرابز - عالم بنت
تصاميمنا وابداعاتنا
تصاميم
تصميم
فوتوشوب
حقيبة المصمم
البوم صور التصاميم
دروس الفوتوشوب والايميج ردي
عالم حواء
عالم مائدتك
عالم الطب و الصحه
عالم الديكور
عالم الصور المنوعه
عالم القصص و الروايات
العاب بنات
مسنجر-صور مسنجر-توبيكات-مسن
ام ام اس - وسائط - كل مايخص الجوال
توبيكات
توبيك
ماسنجر
صور للتصميم
صور بنات للتصميم
سكرابز قلوب
سكرابز 2009
فساتين 2009
فساتين 2010
Related Searches
Google Top Search
Google Top Trend
Online News Today
Entertainment News Today
News Gadget New
All About Network
Cell Phone Review
Video Plane
Cheap Hotels
Free Cell Phone
Daily News
http://www.icfshop.com
Christmas is around the corner: And old customers can also enjoy the gifts sent by my company in a can also request to our company. Gifts lot,Buy more get the more。Only this site have this treatmentOur goal is "Best quality, Best reputation , Best services". Your satisfaction is our main pursue. You can find the best products from us, meeting your different needs.
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s28 (JORDAN SHOES)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s1 (ED HARDY)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s11 (JEANS)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s6 (TSHIRTS)
New to Hong Kong : Winter Dress
---**** NHL Jersey Woman $ 40 ---**** NFL Jersey $ 35 --**** NBA Jersey $ 34 ---**** MLB Jersey $ 35 ---**** Jordan Six Ring_m $36 ---**** Air Yeezy_m $ 45 ---**** T-Shirt_m $ 25 ---**** Jacket_m $ 36 ---**** Hoody_m $ 50 ---****Manicure Set $ 20
HOT SELL Product Brand is below: Nike Air Jordan(1-25)/Jordan Six Ring/Jordan Fusion/Nike Shox/Air Max/AF1/Dunk: $32 Polo/Ed Hardy/Lacoste/Ca/A&F ……T-shirt:Coach /Gucci/Lv/Ed Hardy/D&G/Fendi ……Handbag:$35 Christian Louboutin/Lv/Ed Hardy/Gucci/Coach/Lacoste/ Timbland……True Religion/Coogi/Evisu/Ed Hardy/Prada ……Jeans:$30 New era/Gucci/Ed hardy ……cap : $13 Okely/Coach/D&G/Fendi/Gucci/Armani …sunglass:$15Nike shoes: 32$, True Religion jeans:30$, Ed Hardy, t-shirts:12$, NFL Jersey:20$,Boots UGG:50$
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s65 (HANDBAGS)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s2 (Air_max_man)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s29 (Nike shox)
http://www.icfshop.com/productlist.asp?id=s6 (Polo tshirt)
Welcome to Shopping →→→ http://www.icfshop.com
I wish you a happy shopping
P.S. And I am not worried about the PAKS- if they so much as fart too loud the Indians will smash them like a bug.
George W. got us into that one with no real way out. As far as I'm concered, that's his war. And as long as we're on the subject, I'd hate to see Al Qaeda and the Taliban get those nukes.
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
العاب دولز
@ Grey,
Funny how after all of our chest thumping and posturing we come to the same conclusion! I feel the same way you do but I'm leaning more towards just getting out of both countries. I believe the problem may be deeper than dems versus republicans but you may be on to something there. Either way things like that happen all the time in politics, the sad thing is the soldiers get to be the pawns this time. I honestly think people are stuck on the fact that we have some moral obligation to build back up what we destroyed and that is the elephant in the room. The military is meant to close with and destroy the enemy, we are not nation builders or police. It is mainly because of this reason that no real strategy has been formed. If we go in and conduct unlimited war the world will condemn us, if we keep shifting the ROE to facilitate winning hearts and minds and nation building we will be in Afghanistan/Iraq forever. Maybe someone with some sense will wake up and realize you can't wage war on an idea (war on terror, drugs, etc.).
Welcome to Shopping →→→ http://www.dudemalls.com
Best quality, Best reputation , Best services
With our advanced manufacturing, production lines and well-organized sales networks, we can provide many products, such as apparel, shoes, caps, handbags, etc.
Our goal is "the best quality, best reputation and best services". Your satisfaction is our main pursue. You can find the best products from us, meeting your different needs.
HOT SELL Product Brand is below:
Nike Air Jordan(1-25)/Jordan Six Ring/Jordan Fusion/Nike Shox/Air Max/AF1/Dunk: $32
Polo/Ed Hardy/Lacoste/Ca/A&F ……T-shirt:
Coach /Gucci/Lv/Ed Hardy/D&G/Fendi ……Handbag:$35
Christian Louboutin/Lv/Ed Hardy/Gucci/Coach/Lacoste/ Timbland……Shoe :$35
True Religion/Coogi/Evisu/Ed Hardy/Prada ……Jeans:$30
New era/Gucci/Ed hardy ……cap : $13
Okely/Coach/D&G/Fendi/Gucci/Armani ……sunglass : $15
Nike shoes: 32 $, True Religion jeans: 30 $, Ed Hardy, t-shirts: 12 $, NFL Jersey: 20 $, Boots UGG: 50 $
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s18 (JORDAN SHOES)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s22 (ED HARDY)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s69 (Handbag)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s6 (TSHIRTS)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s76 (Jacket)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s77 (Hoody_m)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s1 (NHL Jersey)
http://www.dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=s3 (NBA Jersey)
http://dudemalls.com/productlist.asp?id=n316 (Photoshop CS4)