Jack White and Melissa Harris-Lacewell Chat with Washington Post Readers
_______________________
washingtonpost.com: Rought Sketch: For Obama, a Voice of Doom?
_______________________
Washington, D.C.: Do you think Wright accurately represents an older generation belief if any at all in the black community? Is what he says representative of how young black citizens feel?
Jack White: I think there are many people in the black community who agree with Wright. And others who don't agree with him who will rally to his defense out of a sense of racial solidarity. I'm not sure how this divides generationally, but I suspect this might be an issue on which the young and old agree.
Melissa Harris-Lacewell: There is a bit of a generational divide here.My father is certainly of a generation that never trusts that white voters will be reasonable and durable coalition partners. But had I lived through Jim Crow I might easily have felt the same way. It is easy to judge harshly those who survived so much.
_______________________
Washington, DC..: I listened to the NAACP speech, watched the Moyers interview, and listened to the transcript. I have new and great respect for Rev. Wright, and agreed with him on many points.
My questions: What portions of the press conference do you believe will be most repeated/maligned, and why?
And (I'm assuming this by the talk of ego and hubris) why don't you believe the attacks on Rev. Wright are the narrow form of a larger attack against black churches?
Jack White: Well, it will come down to soundbites again. Maybe the one in which he expounded on the idea that 9/11 was chickens coming home to roost. There were plenty.
I don't think that the criticism of Wright was an attack on all black churches because they are all different, don't subscribe to the same ideas, and don't deserve to be found guilty by association with Wright.
_______________________
Raleigh, N.C.: Why do you claim "while candidates with nearly lily-white electoral bases are allowed to avoid the question altogether" regarding race? Is Clinton's base 'lily-white'? I thought Hispanic voters were a very important part of her supporters. Also, former President Clinton was taken to task for mentioning that Jessie Jackson had won S.C. primary when he ran.
This is part of an unwinnable debate -- if Clinton gets the white votes in Pa., it is because of the Bradley effect, yet if Obama gets 90 percent plus of the African American vote that is viewed differently.
In view of the large gulf in how topics of race or around race are viewed, aren't Wright's placing Obama in a no-win scenario? If he does not throw Wright under the bus he loses moderate white votes, if he does he loses some percentage of black support?
Jack White: You have accurately described Obama's dilemma, which happens to be the same one any black candidate faces running in a mostly white political landscape. Obama's candidacy raises the question squarely: can a black win enough votes to get to the White House? The only way to know if for a black candidate like Obama to run.
_______________________
Washington, D.C.: Do you think Obama will ignore this latest news from Rev. Wright? Or do you think he will address it? Has there been any reaction yet from Barack Obama?
Jack White: His campaign strategist, David Axelrod, tried to handle it prememptively by pointing out that Wright is a free agent over whom Obama has no control. But I think Obama is going to have to say something about this. Don't know if he has yet, or when he will.
_______________________
Boston, Mass.: But Rev. Wright is a smart man, he must know 'it would all come down to soundbytes again.' Why do you think he chose to pepper his speeches with as many soundbyte-ready comments as he did?
Jack White: Who knows why he is doing what he's doing? He's not exactly a shrinking violent, is he?
_______________________
Richmond, Va.: Istn't this really just a disagreement between the old guard (the Sharptons, Wrights and Jackson) vs. the new guard (Obama). The old guard was the fiery group who had their window on the world while Obama has a different one. Maybe the old guard doesn't want to get out of the limelight yet.
Jack White: I think there's something to this. Wright is now a lot more famous than he was a few weeks ago. And I do think that Jackson, Sharpton and the older generation of black leaders, many of them clergymen, worry about being pushed off stage by young upstarts, who occupy offices the older ones could never get, have realistic dreams of becoming president, and are seen as potential leaders of all the people, not just blacks.
_______________________
Ottawa, Canada: Is Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright Jr. running for president? No. So, what's the big deal? Ronald Reagan, when running for president, was supported by some controversial people. Reagan simply said, "He supports me. That doesn't mean I support him." Why doesn't Obama just say something like that?
Melissa Harris-Lacewell: I agree! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE , do not vote for Reverend Wright for the US Presidency!
Jack White: Well,I agree that Obama should have done a better job of separating himself. As for Reagan, well, let's just say I don't agree with your analysis. I think he sought the support of some awful pepole.
Discuss:
Jack White and Melissa Harris-Lacewell Chat with Washington Post Readers
Member Comments
-
Posted By:
-
Posted By:
-
Posted By:
View All Comments »jumpman at 04/30/2008 10:26:53 AM
Comment:
What's that saying about a barrel of crabs? Why do we always pull each other back? I really think this man wants his 15 minutes of fame, he needs to find another stage to get it.
dmac225 at 04/30/2008 6:00:15 AM
Comment:
During the discussion both JW and MHL asked why McCain and Clinton have almost no black supporters. The reason for this they claim is that neither Clinton nor McCain has done enough to try to draw more blacks into their bases. I think JW and MHL should open their eyes to who the real racists are. Over 90% of black Americans who have voted in this primary voted for Obama and yet you have the audacity to blame McCain and Clinton for not having a lot of black people supporting them.. Gee, I wonder why that is? If 90% of white voters had voted for McCain or Clinton you would be screaming racism from the tallest mountain.
If Clinton is not nominated do you think women will riot? Can you say the same about the "black community" if Obama is not nominated and/or elected as President? Until all of the hyphenated Americans (African-American, Mexican-American, etc.) decide to drop the hyphenation and just be Americans there is no "moving forward"..
techieb1 at 04/30/2008 1:01:38 AM
Comment:
Watching Rev. Wright on Sunday was like watching a train wreck. It was horrible to hear him mock past leaders (as well as the dead) but I could not turn the channel. And I heard Monday's comments were worse! Wright is the worst traitor, because Barack has sacrificed his good name to remain in Wright's life. The game has changed now. A true friend would never turn on his friend or threaten him even in the worst of fights, and so I really think that Rev. Wright is mentally deficient, immature, and possibly toxic, bipolar, or narcissistic. Either way, Barack has never said any hateful things out of his own mouth, and I believe him when he says that he has never seen that side of Wright. Maya A. said when people show you who they are the first time believe them. So, why is SHE supporting Hillary who told blatant lies about her past? I saw a woman flip on her "friend" and unleash a character assassination, and it shocked me so much to see the "Three faces of Eve". God will judge us all, and Barack will come out on top because he tried to forgive Wright. Wright has never learned to forgive America for her injustices. It is sad to watch a Black man as book smart as Rev. Wright self destruct.