Skip Navigation
Cancel
[ Top Five Views ]
Keith Josef Adkins

SECOND GUESSING MY PATRIOTISM

Rebecca Walker

MY SON WILL NOT STOP TALKING. It's driving me mad.

Jimi Izrael

IF YOU'RE DOING IT BIG, Sen. Barack Obama thinks you could give a little more come tax time.

Melissa Harris-Lacewell

THE 4TH OF JULY weekend is nearly here. I don't know about you, but I have mixed emotions about this holiday.

Marc Lamont Hill

AS MUCH AS I enjoy a good Obama-bash, I have to disagree with you on this one. Given your penchant for calling me idealistic and naïve about therealpolitik of presidential campaigns, I'm surprised that you're tripping about UnityFest 2008.

Veronica Chambers

SUMMER SUPPER: Soft Shell Crabs & Corn, Avocado and Tomato Salad

[ Views ]

Notes on a Negress

In a new exhibition, Kara Walker's silhouettes explore the moist, violent, conflicted conceptual terrain of American race and sexuality. But is there Hope?

 Collection Donna and Cargill MacMillan
Kara Walker: "Cut" 1998
Type Size

April 15, 2008

"I can no more disown him than I can disown the black community. I can no more disown him than I can my white grandmother - a woman who helped raise me, a woman who sacrificed again and again for me, a woman who loves me as much as she loves anything in this world, but a woman who once confessed her fear of black men who passed by her on the street, and who on more than one occasion has uttered racial or ethnic stereotypes that made me cringe."

Barack Obama

"I remember wanting to be the heroine, but I remember also wanting to kill the heroine at the same time."

– Kara Walker

In the 16 years since her 1994 debut, 38-year-old Kara Walker has arguably become the best known and most feted African American visual artist of her era. "Kara Walker: My Complement, My Enemy, My Oppressor, My Love," her current retrospective now on view at Los Angeles' Hammer Museum, is a high-profile honor for an artist so young. Walker's cut-paper silhouettes -- the antic, bruising, racial fever-dream her sharp black shapes and blobs depict -- are already an unmistakable visual signature.

Since her 1994 coming-out at New York's Drawing Center with "Gone, An Historical Romance of a Civil War as It Occurred Between the Dusky Thighs of One Young Negress and Her Heart," a huge diorama that mixed Gone with the Wind with Birth of a Nation, Walker has steadily toiled the same patch of soil to create the interconnected body of work on view in My Complement, My Enemy.

From 10,000 feet, Walker's art uses the techniques of Victorian-era paper silhouetting and shadow projections to explore the moist, violent, conflicted conceptual terrain of American racial fantasy and paranoia. Her subject matter is invariably the sexual violence of the Civil War South as simultaneously exposed and repressed in her riffs on the era's lingering fictions: The Clansman, Birth of a Nation, Gone with the Wind, Uncle Tom's Cabin, any and all depictions of black and white sexuality since. (The "heroine" Walker wants to both embody and garrote was Wind's Scarlett O'Hara.) Her cut-paper silhouettes are themselves full of typically 19th Century gentility and repression. If you were to flip them over, you'd spy the skillfully rendered and underlying armature of the full-on drawings the cut-outs once were: Walker's career-making technique submerges her own ability to make marks with ink and paint in favor of marks made with matte-black paper and an X-Acto knife.

Walker's is a strangely frictionless universe despite all the rubbing up and penetrating it depicts. Heads, broom handles, and kitchen knives disappear into black and white mouths, vaginas and, well, asses unimpeded by the pretense of internal anatomy.

Each silhouette is at turns a blow-up doll, Russian doll or Trojan horse capable of accommodating literal Civil War-era armies. In one cutout, a girl stands atop a fountain, water impossibly gushing out of her mouth, nipple, armpit. (She is both inhuman and ecstatic, empty and emblematic. The point of entry for this magical stream? The sole of her foot.)

In another series called "Negress Notes," a black girl floats like a hot air balloon tethered to a tree by a noose, the usual vectors of gravity, which is to say lynching, reversed. Another wall-sized piece includes the smallish, isolated detail of young man floating high in the air, his body held aloft by the zeppelin-like powers of his enormous, inflated penis. 

Kara Walker, Negress Notes (Brown Follies) 1996–1997 Watercolor on paper. Collection Michael and Joan Salke, Naples, Florida.

Walker is clearly a lover of puns, and so the show includes many of her text-based work, like 1997's "Do You Like Crème in Your Coffee and Chocolate in Your Milk," which exclaims: "Towards a more perfect African, which is what blk-Americans tend to choose. To reclaim one's righteous place on the throne of Africa!"

Black middle class dreams and heroisms – first this, first that; inventor of the streetlight; secret first man to the North Pole – take on imperial overtones black folks usually attribute to God-complex-having white men. Another torn sheet simply wonders whether the solution to lingering white stereotypes will always be dearly-held black stereotypes, an endless exchange of tit for tat.

To call the overall effect shocking doesn't do the work justice, as the shifting impulses Walker captures in paper with her knife, her sharp lines of guilt, shame, pride and desire, have divided audiences as much as they have challenged and amused them. In 1997 walker was rewarded for her trouble (making) with the double whammy of a MacArthur Foundation "genius grant" and a reactive call for a nationwide Kara Walker boycott led by black conceptual artist Betye Saar, who called Walker's work "revolting and negative and a form of betrayal to the slaves, particularly women and children. [I]t [is] basically for the amusement and the investment of the white art establishment."

[ Page ]

Discuss:

Notes on a Negress

Member Comments

  • Posted By:
    falseprophet at 04/17/2008 7:37:06 AM
    Comment:
    I think part of the debate we need to have is "Why should her art be redemptive?" and "What is that redemption supposed to look like?" Her art is not only based on the historical, but also the personal -- and I don't mean in a Collective Unconscious kind of way. In a New Yorker article, she discussed her experiences in a relationship with a white man and how she realized it was both destructive and addictive, which informs some of the complex sexual politics she depicts in her work. Both black men and women complain about the other gender's "trespasses" into interracial relationships with white, sometimes even arguing that there is no such thing as a healthy interracial relationship between white and black. I find the attitude to be repugnant, but I do not expect Walker's art to reflect my attitudes about race, sex, and love just because she and I are both black. If she, in fact, sees no route to some concept of "redemption," I see no reason to criticize her work on that grounds. In fact, I am wondering just what this "redemption" is supposed to look like. A moratorium on all white-black relationships? I doubt it.
  • Posted By:
    falseprophet at 04/17/2008 7:24:07 AM
    Comment:
    I think part of that debate has to be "Why must her art be redemptive?" In interviews she has mentioned that much of the complex sexual politics he depicts in her art are also directly autobiographical -- and I don't mean in a 'collective unconscious' kind of way. In a New Yorker article she discussed a relationship she had with a white man which she came to realize was destructive, yet addictive. And with complaints from both black men and women about the other gender's "trespasses" into relationships with whites, which doesn't seem to see an end, where is the redemption? What does it look like? Perhaps there won't be any "redemption" until all black-white interracial relationships have ceased, since there is always a way to read into them some kind of oppression by the white partner upon the black partner. There seems to be a sense these days that there's no such thing as a healthy interracial relationship between black and white, which is an attitude I find repugnant, if only for the gross generalization that founds its premise. So I wonder if asking for her art to be "redemptive" is asking it to show something that we have not found yet, which we haven't found yet partially because we've not defined it. Walker's art appears to be personal as well as historical, and in so far as she personally has not found "redemption" that she can put in her art I see no reason for depict it, even if some of her detractors seem to believe that they have.
  • Posted By:
    irene at 04/16/2008 8:43:19 AM
    Comment:
    The "artistry" of Walker's work is subjective - and I have long agreed with Saar on the nature of how "well" her work has been receieved. As a Gen-Xer and historian of the Black female experience I find nothing redemptive in her work. There is angst and speculation that could have existed, however, we "average" citizen have not evolved to that level of intellectual liberation and responsibility for the vile and degenerate nature that enslavement caused all humanity to experience.
    I think being critical of her does not require an entire "witchhunt" locking her out of museums, however, there needs to be some interdisciplinary discussion by historians, psychologists, artists and others to deconstruct the meaning and message of her work - and please since this is America let her continue to create from whatever source is driving her - and since this is America, let me whet my tongue and speak out against such atrocious monstrocities.
View All Comments »