Black Women Are Not Feeling the Feminists' Pain
Is the sisterhood in peril?
March 17, 2008 -- Note to Geraldine Ferraro, Gloria Steinem, and complainer in chief, Hillary Clinton: Get over yourselves.
Your cries of reverse racism, your complaints about overt sexism in the campaign, your vocal protests about media favoritism being shown BarackObama, ring hollow.
We are not feeling your pain. None of you are symbolic of female oppression. You are all well-educated and well-connected. You are influential and have ready access to the media. You have had more opportunities than most black women could ever dream of and we doubt you could ever relate to the level of sexism and racism we regularly face. We know you couldn't even begin to understand what it's like for black men.
Last time we checked, none of you were struggling with the challenges that average working women – both black and white – deal with everyday: making ends meet, finding safe and affordable childcare, paying the rent or mortgage, getting jobs that pay a living wage and offer opportunities for advancement. Amid all of this, regular working women are trying to find personal fulfillment and build a sense of self.
You privileged ladies already have a huge sense of self, and an even bigger sense of entitlement. Your words have only served to widen the divide between us and you, and your faulty and misguided perspective that Obama, a black man, is the enemy only serves to underline the divide.
Obama is not getting a free pass because he's black; he's getting more scrutiny because of it. He did not get where he is simply because he's a black man; he got where he is in spite of it. Your piling on Obama is one very warped expression of "girl power."
Somehow we don't believe this was what Betty Friedan was thinking when she wrote The Feminine Mystique in 1963 and launched the modern women's movement. The movement was built on the premise that women were smarter than men believed, wanted more than men felt they deserved, were more ambitious than men were comfortable with, and had dreams bigger than the boundaries men set for them. It was about being politically affirming, not politically divisive.
The movement was not about being nasty, and calculating, and intellectually dishonest. And it was definitely not about playing dirty politics – like men. You make us wonder if you ever were really one of us now that we clearly see you have become one of "them."
Hillary Clinton, earlier in the campaign you complained that your Democratic opponents were "piling on" and "taking a page from the Republican playbook." The truth is you've taken a page directly from Karl Rove's playbook and appropriated his defining doctrine of win at any cost, take no prisoners, and when everything else fails, resort to shameless race baiting. How unoriginal.
The sisterhood, at least your version of it, has been unmasked. You have proven you will do and say whatever it takes to win, even if that means doing irreparable harm to your political party and the good relationship you once had with black women. Honest and fair political discourse is being hijacked by your hypocrisy and that is certain to hurt the genuine efforts of white and black women working hard to form alliances on common and larger feminist causes.
Geraldine Ferraro, you said that Obama was "lucky" to be where he is and should "thank" you.
"In all honesty, do you think that if he were a white male, there would be a reason for the black community to get excited for a historic first?" You asked. "Am I pointing out something that doesn't exist?"
What you fail to point out is that black people overwhelmingly voted for Bill Clinton for president not once, but twice. And we did the same for John Kerry, Al Gore, and other white candidates that came before them. Over the years, black voters have also supported plenty of white female candidates for Congress – including Hillary Clinton – and in statewide races.
When many Americans turned their backs on BillClinton after Monica Lewinsky and impeachment, black people stood by him as steadfastly as they would any member of their family. That's because we believe deeply in the power of forgiveness and redemption, but if you and other Clinton cohorts keep this up, we won't be so forgiving at the polls, even if Clinton is the nominee.
We remember, Geraldine, that you also derided Jesse Jackson when he ran for president in 1988. "If Jesse Jackson were not black, he wouldn't be in the race," you said then. Your comments then, and now, seem to consistently imply that no black male candidate can legitimately run for office or engage voters with his ideas, policies proposals or vision for a better America. We can probably guess what you think of black women candidates.
Discuss:
Black Women Are Not Feeling the Feminists' Pain
Member Comments
-
Posted By:
-
Posted By:
-
Posted By:
View All Comments »Compton Kid at 06/09/2008 9:59:04 PM
Comment:
Geraldine, Hillary, and Gloria, your profound indignation has been duly noted. I offer to each of you the same response that Black women and men have received for years. . . . . "GET OVER IT, LET IT GO, THAT'S HISTORY. Oh yeah, can't forget the ultimate one -- "No one in my family had anything to do with it." Anyway, some of my best friends are entitled white women that have NO excuse for not reaching their potential because the world has been served to them on a platter ALL of their lives.
Personally, I find it unacceptable when you, and others like you, attempt to bring doubt,to the legitimacy of Senator Obama's political candidacy, but you, nor your mothers, grandmothers, or great grandmothers have ever had the nerve to hold your own men ACCOUNTABLE for the sexist lives they inflicted upon each of you.
Geraldine, I'd work on my own house first. Hillary, what can I say. Yours is a lost cause --- no pun intended. And Gloria, well "it's your thang do what you wanna do".
deemill at 06/04/2008 1:19:23 PM
Comment:
Comment: You guys of the liberal leftist media are something. After trashing Hillary because he is a woman and somewhat less liberal than Obama. Now you elevating an inexperienced man to the level of Greek mythology. I bet you if Hillary went to dinner at the so-called Rev. Wright 3 or 4 times, you hyppocrite of the media would trash her even more and call for her resignation. You are something! You sexist media will have the shock of your life when your little creation name Barack Hussein Obama will be sent back to South Chicago where he belongs to reunite with his friend Weathermen leader Bernadine Dohrn and Ayers (terrorists and criminals), RezKo (criminal), his spiritual leaders of 17 to 20 years Farrakhan, Wright and Pfleger (racists and anti-semitic), his racist wife Michelle (review her thesis, listen to her own comments, wait the upcoming tape). So how many pass are you derranged leftist going to give him. Are you guilty for your ancestors racisms? are you you mentally sick with your liberalism? Do you hate America so much by your communism? Do you hate George Bush so much that you are willing to put your ego first? At least george Bush never insulted America! After alll according to you, he stealed the election From Gore by getting elected when Gore won the popular vote. Why are you not outrage when Obama steal the nomination when Hillary won the popular vote? why don't you cry foul play when Obama got awarded with delegates when he removed voluntary his name on the ballot in Michgan? What are you not defending reverse racism and sexism? Your double standard is sickening. But get what? we the real American women and men for that matter, will be getting revenge in November and will send your little fictional creation named Barack Hussein Obama back with the terrorists that he belongs in the South side of Chicago.
Datdamwuf at 03/29/2008 3:40:08 PM
Comment:
thank you for this post, as a "white" woman I can't know about racism but I have certainly experienced sexism. I am highly successful with no degree but it took many years and having to always work harder and longer than the males around me. I'm 40 something, when I went into IT I was the ONLY woman I knew in the profession, when I moved into IT security I rarely saw a woman. That has changed, and in my lifetime! I am proud that us old feminists managed to break some barriers so that younger women no longer think our issues are their issues. It means we made progress, I love that both black and white women are represented in my field now. Hopefully those younger women can bridge the wage gap and move the glass ceiling up a few rungs in their lifetimes.
Lastly, I for one am glad that those "privileged ladies" stood up for us and helped us get the vote, get into jobs we need, and all the other things they've done. Honestly, when you are working all the time you aren't likely to be the activist who has time to truly organize and make the difference. Those "privileged ladies" made a contribution to our equality with the help of many more less fortunate.