Skip Navigation
Cancel
[ Top Five Views ]
Keith Josef Adkins

LIGHT SKINNED PRIVILEGE: Black in America

Rebecca Walker

I LOVE MICHELLE OBAMA. And I couldn't be happier she's started blogging.

Jimi Izrael

THERE'S NO ROOM for Floaters in America. Not anymore.

[ Views ]

Immersion Therapy

Surviving on a blackness-only diet.

Getty Images
Type Size

 

Feb. 13, 2008--Not my idea, not really. Credit mostly belongs to a poet friend of mine.

We were discussing some independent movie by an unknown black director he had just seen at a special screening at his local art house. It would be cool, said The Poet, to be able to see more movies like that, movies by black writers and directors. Perhaps even see only movies like that, for some designated period of time.

"Sure," said I. "See only movies which reflect us and our experience."

"Only black movies," said The Poet. "Also, read only black books and magazines."

"And listen to black music," said I. "And get all your news from black newspapers and websites."

"For maybe a year," said The Poet.

"A year of black culture," said I, buzzing now. "Imagine the experience. Imagine how one's perspective might change and shift."

"Either that," said The Poet, "Or the effort would drive you insane."

Fear of insanity not being a deterrent, I decided to try. It would be a grand experiment, an attempt to immerse myself in the warm waters of blackness, to swim beyond the sight of whiteness land.

American culture is black culture, of course. The music, the language, the food, the literature, the very definition of what it means to be American – all of it is shot straight through with us. Try to remove the African presence from the house that is America and the whole thing collapses upon itself. Ask Toni Morrison. And yet those contributions are still too often marginalized or minimized, or gotten just plain wrong, even when told through well-intentioned voices. Anyone but me roll their eyes through the movie Hairspray? What's up with the equation of black struggle with physical stoutness? Why did the white girl have to tell the black folks to stand up for themselves? And why or why were all the black kids spending their school days dancing in detention? Shouldn't somebody protest that?

No, the great writer John Oliver Killens was right when he insisted on the revolutionary power of writing, and the need for people of color to tell their own stories. And to read them and watch them and hear them, too.

Sometimes a body needs a break from the dominant description of things.

Two days into my experiment and I come home to find The New Yorker in the mail. My first thought: well, guess I have to give that up. My second thought: Huh, that's interesting.

I mean, The New Yorker? Half the time I can't even stand it. Half the time the latest white-boy navel-gazing issue goes right in the trash. Why would I even consider that a giving-up instead of a clearing away? A making of space for something else? Hegemony anyone?

Books are easy. I have my own stash, plus the Boston public library is incredibly helpful. Weeks before, when visiting an unfamiliar branch, I'd asked the white librarian at the desk for directions to the fiction stacks. She kindly pointed them out, then added, unprompted, "All the African-American books are marked with a little red sticker." At the time I was looking for Doris Lessing – but hey. It's always good to mark the black books so folks can find them. Or not.

Movies are better than I might have thought. Among the choices I would never ordinarily make: Norbit, Code Name: The Cleaner and Stomp the Yard. Among the choices that I would: Dreamgirls, The Last King of Scotland, The Pursuit of Happyness. Blood Diamond is still around but I decide it does not count. God Grew Tired of Us: The Story of Lost Boys of Sudan is likewise lurking next door to Boston, in the People's Republic of Cambridge, but I lack the spirit to go.

 Even among the best of these, how many of them are really "black films?" How honestly do they reflect some aspect of black experience, or not? And to what extent are they the result of black creative forces behind the camera and behind the desk, as opposed to just the faces out front?

These are questions I do not ask myself, not yet. It is enough to sit in the dark and stare up at some pretty brown faces on the screen. Television is fleeting. Teaching late and parenting later keeps me from the tube until 9:30 or ten, and none of the shows I usually find to fill that hour before bed manage to meet my requirements. They fail even when I, in a fit of weakness, amend it from "must be black-created, inspired or produced" (also good, which eliminated Grey's Anatomy) to "must feature a cast that is at least 25 percent black, in regular, reasonable, non side-kicky, non-Magic Negro roles. Goodbye Boston Legal. Kiss, kiss, to the guilty pleasure of Nip/Tuck.  Instead I catch Girlfriends and The Game and go to bed.

After a few weeks of this it occurs to me to make use of my college library. In the video collection I find a wonderful documentary about James Baldwin called The Price of the Ticket.  Inspired, I return for one called I'll Make Me a World – also good, but long. Eyes on the Prize after that – wonderful but depressing; By the time the Movement crawls, bloodied and battered to 1961, I can't take anymore.

[ Page ]

Discuss:

Immersion Therapy

Discussion and Submission Guidelines

Member Comments

  • Posted By:
    TRUBLUBU2 at 02/17/2008 5:43:17 PM
    Comment:
    yes, these things do happen WITH REGULARITY. the incident described rings VERY true for me, as i've experienced it many times in various venues???regional location in this country had NOTHING to do with it.

    i learned to choose my battles and continue onto the more important destination instead of giving attention to constant, wearying slights???that???s on good days. on bad days, however, my reaction can range from outright rage to entering into light depression. that???s what being thought of as a thing and not an individual can do to a person.

    what???s the point of filing a complaint? who???s going to care? what???s going to be done with the complaint? if that???s the case, perhaps i should file a complaint against the whole western hemisphere, being that these slights can come from anyone, at any time, anywhere???right?
  • Posted By:
    carvell at 02/17/2008 11:22:12 AM
    Comment:
    Being a black person around a majority of white people and things is difficult. I'm not complaining about it or claiming oppression, it's just one of those things in life that's difficult. I can see why a person would feel like it's some kind of relief to go "back to black." (Even though,. when her poet friend suggested that she might go insane, I didn't think it'd be from the effort, but from all the stupid, insipid, juvenile, and ridiculous Black stuff she'd eventually have to read, watch and listen to.)

    This whole thing about "can't we all just be Americans" is interesting. Having black skin doesn't make you black. Navigating the world with black skin makes you black. It has an impact on who you are, what you value and how you live. Much in the same way, perhaps, that being a woman for 30 or 40 or 50 years would form your world view and outlook. It's beyond genetics or chemistry. It's an experience. Of course we're Americans, but we clearly don't feel like when people say "America" they're talking about our experience. So we feel the need to be clear about it, even if it's with the perpetually goofy and much-maligned "African-American" moniker.

    This is one of the main things that make Blackness different from Hispanicness or Irishness, or Cherokeeness. You can see Black people from a mile away (and not just cause we're loud as f*ck, but there's that too). We're always visually identifiable as non-white. All the time, every time. This has had a significant impact on our lived experience and treatment in ways and contexts that are vast and varied. That is why we can't just up and blend in after a few generations. It's the skin and the hair and the lips and the nose and the booty that create the experience.And it's that experience that makes us Black.

    To the whole "replace black with white and you'll see how racist it is" argument. Please. When you replace black with white, other things change as well. For evidence of this, think of every white person you know in your life and neighborhood. Now replace them with black people and see if it don't feel a little different.

    It's true that this piece doesn't really offer much beyond a compelling question: "What would happen if I immersed myself in Black only media for x amount of time?" Unfortunately we never find out what happens because Ms. Mclarin forgets to answer it. She instead takes the opportunity to navel gaze about being black in general and then foray briefly into self-aggrandizing.

    But what's not true is that it's "myopic" or "racist" simply because it wants to calls some things black and other things white. Frankly, that's how it is. Race is not everything. But it's definitely something.


  • Posted By:
    carvell at 02/17/2008 9:35:02 AM
    Comment:
    growing with black skin in america makes you black.
View All Comments »