“Lee Daniels’ The Butler engineered a surprise victory over Morgan Spurlock’s 3D concert documentary One Direction: This Is Us at the Labor Day box office, becoming the first movie of 2013 to top the North American chart three weekends in a row,” Pamela McClintock reported Monday for the Hollywood Reporter.
The book version, “The Butler: A Witness to History,” by Wil Haygood, based on his 2008 Washington Post story, entered the New York Times best-seller list in the Times’ print editions of Sunday. It remains there for the Sept. 8 edition at No. 10 on the “Combined Print & E-Book Nonfiction” list and No. 13 on the “Hardcover Nonfiction” list.
“The success of the movie is overwhelming to me,” Haygood told Journal-isms by email Monday. “I wanted to write about someone who had worked in the shadows at the White House. And now Eugene Allen, who loved his country ferociously, is out of the shadows.” Allen is the real-life butler on whom the movie character is based.
Asked what journalists — especially black journalists — should take away from his success, Haygood replied, “I think a lesson for black journalists is not to shy away from our history, no matter how painful. There are still folks who have a difficult time dealing with the term BUTLER.”
“The Butler” might be the first book-and-movie success ever to come from a newspaper story written by an African American journalist. Haygood also has associate producer’s credit.
The major Hollywood studios turned down the movie, which was ultimately made by the Weinstein Co., Sheila C. Johnson, the co-founder of Black Entertainment Television, explained at Washington’s Politics and Prose bookstore on July 30 as the book was released. Johnson completed the fund-raising required to make the film. “Without her, there would be no ‘Butler’ movie [video],” Haygood said then.
“This is a new day in black film,” Johnson told the packed audience.
McClintock reported, “The Butler, distributed by The Weinstein Co., is one example of a smaller title that has shown remarkable staying power. The historical drama grossed $20 million for the four-day holiday, pushing its domestic total to a $79.3 million. The film’s outstanding run is a testament, at least in part, to Oprah Winfrey’s standing.
“Winfrey stars opposite Forest Whitaker, who plays a White House Butler working through eight presidential administrations. The film — a likely awards contender — is certain to gross north of $100 million.
” ‘The audience continues to broaden out and get younger,’ says TWC distribution chief Erik Lomis.”
Among those in the broadening audience was Carlos Sanchez, editor of the Monitor in McAllen, Texas, who wrote on Aug. 25 that he had taken his 11-year-old daughter to see the film. “I worried that the movie might be too heavy a drama for her and, ultimately, was delighted when she declared that she loved the movie and all its historical references — particularly the civil rights era.
“Then my daughter asked me something profound: ‘Are there any movies like that for Mexicans?’
“I spent more than an hour explaining that the civil rights movement in our country was not only about African-Americans, but Hispanics as well. She was shocked that segregation extended to the Hispanic community.
Sanchez also wrote, “While I enjoyed the conversation with my daughter immensely, I couldn’t help but wonder about the dearth of popular movies that tell the story of Hispanics in America. . . .”
Four historians of Ronald Reagan‘s presidency wrote in the Washington Post on Sunday that “As historians of the 40th president, having written more than a dozen biographies between us, we are troubled by the movie’s portrayal of Reagan’s attitudes toward race.” The movie showed Reagan as the president who ended the dual pay scale between black and white White House employees, although Bill Hamilton, former White House storeroom manager, told ABC News that that distinction should go to Lyndon Johnson.
While the historians defended Reagan as sensitive to black concerns, a Washington Post/ABC News poll in July 1983 found that nine of every 10 blacks said blacks had been hurt and not helped by Reagan’s policies, and seven of 10 said they did not think Reagan cared that they were hurting.
Stephen A. Crockett Jr., Washington Post: ‘The Butler’ and black male identity (Aug. 21)
Eugene Kane, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: An era not as far away as we think (Aug. 23)
Leonard Pitts Jr., Miami Herald: ‘The Butler’ tells story of hard truths (Aug. 20
Reuters: Obama on watching ‘The Butler’ – ‘I did tear up’ (Aug. 27)
Dawn Turner Trice, Chicago Tribune: ‘The Butler’ hits home for Chicago siblings
Hugo Balta, president of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists, struck back again at columnist Ruben Navarrette Jr. Sunday over Navarrette’s commentary on an embarrassing incident in which the Democratic speaker of the California Assembly, John A. Pérez, is said to have pressured NAHJ to remove a Republican from a political panel at its recent convention in Anaheim, Calif.
Navarrette, the most widely syndicated Hispanic columnist in mainstream newspapers, began his column with, “I’m mourning what has become of an old friend. The National Association of Hispanic Journalists became irrelevant as a journalism organization this week at its annual conference in Anaheim,” Calif. On Twitter, he wrote, “NAHJ stands for ‘Not Actual Honest Journalists.’ “
Balta acknowledged that “mistakes were made” and said he took “full responsibility” for the incident. In a response reposted Sunday on voxxi.com, he said of Navarrette, “The sophomoric personal attacks became worse once I called him out on his bombastic approach. This isn’t a concerned journalist or even wounded NAHJ member (on and off again as Navarrette describes). This is a self absorbed, irresponsible pompous opportunist who cut corners in his storytelling in order to increase readership. . . .”
Rafael Olmeda, a former NAHJ president, wrote in a comment under Navarrette’s piece that “this broadside against NAHJ seems to me to lack a basis in reality.”
However, other commenters have sided with Navarrette, who replied on his Facebook page, “Failed NAHJ President Hugo Balta’s narcissistic pouting over the spanking he got in a recent column brings to mind another sore loser: Republican Congressman Lamar Smith, who I scuffled with in 2010 and 2011. . . .”
Balta concluded, “Deep down inside bullies are cowards [whose] bark is often bigger than their bite.
“The difference between people like [Navarrette] is that while those antagonists talk the talk…people like the fine staff and volunteers at NAHJ (and its partners) who produced an outstanding national conference walk the talk.
“School’s out and I’m standing outside, waiting for Navarrette to come out..to call me — but I know he won’t.”
Julio Ricardo Varela, NBCLatino: NAHJ political snafu proves Latinos need to start working together
Julio “Julito” Ricardo Varela, Latino Rebels: The Latest and (Hopefully the Last) Update on NAHJ Political Speaker Panel Fiasco
“Let’s compare a couple of accounts of the mass deaths apparently caused by chemical weapons in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta on August 21, Jim Naureckas wrote Sunday for Fairness & Accuracy In Media. “One account comes from the U.S. government (8/30/13), introduced by Secretary of State John Kerry. The other was published by a Minnesota-based news site called Mint Press News (8/29/13).
” ‘The government account expresses ‘high confidence that the Syrian government carried out a chemical weapons attack’ on August 21. The Mint report bore the headline ‘Syrians in Ghouta Claim Saudi-Supplied Rebels Behind Chemical Attack.’ Which of these two versions should we find more credible? . . .”
These were not the first accounts of chemical warfare in Syria, however. In May, the French newspaper LeMonde reported, “Reporters for Le Monde spent two months clandestinely in the Damascus area alongside Syrian rebels. They describe the extent of the Syrian tragedy, the intensity of the fighting, the humanitarian drama. On the scene during chemical weapons attacks, they bear witness to the use of toxic arms by the government of Bashar al-Assad. . . .”
As Peter Baker and Jonathan Weisman reported Saturday for the New York Times, “President Obama abruptly changed course on Saturday and postponed a military strike against the Syrian government in retaliation for a chemical weapons attack so he could seek authorization first from a deeply skeptical Congress. . . .”
Meanwhile, Ann Curry of NBC News returned from reporting on the plight of Syrian children made refugees by the fighting. “The true face of the Syrian war refugee is not only a child, it’s a child under the age of 11,” she told host David Gregory Sunday on “Meet the Press.”
Children have witnessed their friends killed from exploding shells, Curry said. Eighty percent of them have to deal with their emotions and trauma on their own. “We may be looking at a lost generation because of what these children are enduring. The world has not responded to the needs of these children and the needs of these refugees to the degree they require help.”
When Curry spoke Aug. 24 at the New York convention of the Asian American Journalists Association, she said she had to leave early to report the children’s stories.
Al Jazeera: UN: Syrian refugee numbers cross two million
Charles M. Blow, New York Times: Op-Ed Columnist War-Weariness
Michael Calderone, Huffington Post: Media’s Failures During Iraq War Cast Shadow Over Syria Coverage
Michael Calderone, Huffington Post: As Syria Attack Looms, Few U.S. News Outlets Report From Damascus (Aug. 27)
Tracy Connor, NBC News: Inside a refugee camp with Syria’s ‘lost generation’ (Aug. 26)
Brian Gallagher, USA Today: Why did USA TODAY run photos of Syrians dead, uncovered? Ask USA TODAY
Dale Gavlak and Yahya Ababneh, Mint Press News: EXCLUSIVE: Syrians In Ghouta Claim Saudi-Supplied Rebels Behind Chemical Attack
New York Times: U.S. Assessment of Syrian Use of Chemical Weapons
Tony Norman, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: If only we’d known King’s take on Obama
Eugene Robinson, Washington Post: Obama’s speech remarkable for its context
Ben Sisario, New York Times: For News From Syrian Battleground, a Reliance on Social Media
“It’s not uncommon in African countries like Zimbabwe and Ethiopia for newspapers to be shut, and their editors jailed,” Rodney Sieh wrote Friday in an op-ed in the New York Times under the headline, “Jailed for Journalism.”
“But the newspaper I edit doesn’t operate in a dictatorship. We are in Liberia, the West’s poster child for postwar democracy building. Our president, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, is a Nobel laureate who is celebrated by the likes of Bill Gates, Warren E. Buffett and Bono and has positioned herself as a champion of a free press.
“Having spent the past week in jail and now under armed guard in a hospital since I contracted malaria, I’m not feeling particularly championed.
“Until it was shut down last week, my paper, FrontPage Africa, had been setting a new standard for journalism in West Africa.”
Sieh also wrote, “The libel case that landed me in jail began in 2010, when we published the results of two investigations by the General Auditing Commission, Liberia’s independent corruption watchdog, into the Agriculture Ministry’s accounts. The investigations, which Mrs. Johnson Sirleaf ordered, found nearly $6 million unaccounted for and raised questions about the agriculture minister at the time, Christopher Toe, a former president of the American online university Strayer.
“When Mr. Toe was quietly dismissed from government, he reacted by suing the paper for libel, as well as me and the reporter Samwah Fallah in our personal capacities. . . .”
AllAfrica.com: Condemnations Follow Jailing of Liberian Journalist
Committee to Protect Journalists: Sirleaf urged to reform libel laws, free Rodney Sieh
“Egyptian authorities say they have deported three members of a TV crew working for the English-language version of Qatar-based news broadcaster Al-Jazeera, after they were detained for nearly a week and accused of working illegally,” the Associated Press reported on Sunday.
“An official at the airport says Al-Jazeera English correspondent Wayne Hay, cameraman Adil Bradlow and producer Russ Finn left Cairo for London on Sunday. The three were detained Tuesday with an Egyptian colleague while covering events in Egypt.
“The official says they were deported for working in Egypt without a permit or license to use satellite transmitters. He spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the press. . . .”
Reporters Without Borders said Monday, “Since 3 July, a total of five journalists have been killed, 80 journalists have been arbitrarily detained (with seven still held) and at least 40 news providers have been physically attacked by the police or by pro-Morsi or pro-army demonstrators,” a reference to deposed President Mohammed Morsi.
“These violations of freedom of information have taken place in a highly polarized political environment that has made the situation extremely difficult and dangerous for journalists. . . .”
Al Jazeera: Egypt frees four-member Al Jazeera team
International Press Institute: IPI urges Egypt to release journalists