Why Talking About Race Is Pointless

The issues are more complicated than our "conversation" will concede.

Posted:
 
(Continued from Page 1)

Now, in my experience, clerks often say "May I help you?" on orders to be solicitous, or even because they want to get you to buy more to up their commission. In New York, quite often I get "May I help you?" from black Caribbean and African clerks. I suspect that people like Banks' interviewee are interpreting the clerks' question inaccurately -- at least usually. Yes, I know racism when I see it: I just wrote about a truly racist club owner in this space. I'm talking only about "May I help you?" Is this really, as we are told, a matter of being "trailed" in stores?

And the problem with a "conversation" about it would be that most clerks likely would deny the racism of which they are being accused. The question: How many black people who have felt that the interviewee would be prepared to believe them and concede that they had been mistaken? That's not the result that most seekers of a "conversation" about race are seeking, and thus the conversation would leave us where we are.

And let's not forget that when whites create The Help, about racism in the Old South, the "conversation" is all about how they didn't make the more progressive-minded whites in the story racist enough. And on top of this, quite a few whites feel this way about the movie -- and yet how many will read in this that a conclusively useful "conversation" has been had on this movie or anything else?

It's not that "nobody wants to talk about race." It's that the old ways of talking about it don't work.

Let's say, for instance, that Obama made certain folks happy and started "talking about race." According to our happy warriors' script, he would call for Ebonics lessons and street-cred training for white teachers. He would suggest in a speech that store clerks not say "May I help you?" to black patrons (only for them to then be accused of racism of a different kind). He would urge the civil service to use tests that are easier for black people, and call for the police to ignore inner-city residents seeking the police to rout out gun-battling drug dealers.

Sorry, but I, for one, am glad Obama won't be taking this tack, and the reason he won't is not that he, or anyone else, "doesn't want to talk about race." We talk about race year-round. The result, however, is not a Grand Acknowledgment That Racism Still Exists, but ambiguity, new questions and even frustration.

We should get used to that. No other shoe is going to drop. There is nothing we are not talking about. Rather, we are dealing with what, in most provinces, is called real life.

John McWhorter is a contributing editor to The Root.

Like The Root on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter.

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.