Is This Obama Education Official Going Too Far?

Russlynn Ali, the Education Department's top civil rights official, is sailing past her critics to ensure equal access for black students.

Posted:
 
(Continued from Page 1)

One day after the Education Department issued the document, University of Iowa officials announced that they would adjust their sexual assault policy to bring it up to par with federal guidelines. A week later, both Yale and Stanford lowered their standard of proof required to take action in sexual assault cases.

Cracking Down on Discrimination

The office has also seen success on a local, case-by-case basis:

* In Newberry, S.C., students in the district's predominantly black high school had none of the Advanced Placement courses that were offered at the school attended by mostly white students. As a result of an investigation, the district agreed to make AP options available to African-American students, and increase outreach to black parents about college-prep courses.

* After examining disciplinary practices in St. James Parish, La. -- where white students' parents were notified after a first behavioral offense, while black students were routinely given detentions or expulsions for the same first-time incidents -- the district changed its procedures to stop the arbitrary exercise of school discipline and trained its faculty to ensure consistent consequences for all students.

* A new charter school in Beaufort, S.C., opened in 2009 with a mostly white student population recruited from private schools. Per an agreement with OCR, the school has increased the enrollment of African-American students by more than 50 percent, recruited black parents to its board of directors and increased the number of minority staff members.

Ali points to such cases as inspiring triumphs. Yet some observers accuse OCR of bad policy. At worst: disturbing government intrusion. "If Department of Education officials intended to demonstrate a penchant for gratuitous bureaucratic overreach and disregard for individual rights, they've succeeded," Atlantic columnist Wendy Kaminer wrote in an article criticizing OCR's strong anti-bullying stance. The office warns that school bullying and harassment often violate protected civil rights.

"Safety is already a major problem in many larger urban schools, where it's not uncommon for students to pass through metal detectors each morning. If districts are afraid to suspend students for fear of an OCR probe, a bad situation is made worse," said a Wall Street Journal editorial. "And if AP classes will now be monitored for racial balance, schools will resort to quotas, lower standards or no longer offer the courses."

Ali insists that she's gotten only positive feedback from the thousands of schools her office has contacted. "I have heard about overreach from commentators and policymakers. I have not actually heard that from a superintendent or a school president," she says with a wry smile. "The things that we have heard from school and university officials are, 'Thank you' and 'You are helping to make us better,' because this is about us working together to do what's right for kids."

Mind the Gap

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.