A Matter of Law: What Everyone Is Missing About the Texas Child Support Case

Clifford Hall was sentenced to six months in jail for missing child support payments, even though he caught up and overpaid as soon as he realized what was happening. His lawyer Tyesha Elam says this isn’t a case of a crooked judge or a deadbeat dad—it’s about the law.

Posted:
 
1389098627

Clifford Hall

YouTube

Clifford Hall is not a deadbeat dad.

And District Court Judge Lisa Millard, who sentenced him to six months in prison even after he caught up and overpaid on his late child support due to a clerical error, is not a crooked judge.

The problem, insists Hall’s lawyer Tyesha Elam, is the law—more specifically, a law that Texas passed in June 2013 repealing protections for parents paying child support who may fall behind.

“I think that people are not recognizing that we have a local change in the law that allowed this result. People are so desirous of blaming the judge or blaming [Hall] that they’re just not hearing when I say the problem is the law,” Elam told The Root on Friday, during the same week her client turned himself in. “Across the country when people get behind in child support, the desire is for them to purge by making a substantial or total payment. That’s universal, that’s the goal: Pay your child support.

“Here in Texas we had an actual statute passed in 2007 that says if you purge and pay all that you owe, then not only will we take jail off the table, we’ll just pursue other alternatives if you pay up. What happened June 14, 2013, is that protection was repealed, and so our laws legally said that if a person falls behind—and even if they paid up—they can still go to jail, and that’s what I think people are missing,” Elam explained.

“This couldn’t have happened in June 2012. This couldn’t have happened in May 2013, but [Hall’s case] happened November 2013, after the law changed, and so what I’m trying to do is get the word out because I want ... federal purging protection,” she continued. “I want the Supreme Court or [Congress] to come down and say everybody has the right to fix [their payment problems]. ... In Texas our parents lost that right in June 2013.”

Elam also doesn’t blame the state legislature for its attempt to hold parents accountable who go month after month without making payments until the law starts “jiggling the keys” to take them to jail. In her mind, these types of deadbeat parents were the real targets of the changed law. Elam knows them well and has gone after a few herself. She relates the story of one case in which she was representing a plaintiff, and the defendant purposely quit a job so he wouldn’t have to make payments. Then he was threatened with jail and somehow coughed up thousands of dollars.

“The [Texas] attorney general’s office is getting frustrated. We should be able to incarcerate [these people] because they willfully fell behind ... I fully agree. Unfortunately our statute doesn’t protect the person that does not willfully fall behind,” the 42-year-old, who has been licensed to practice law in Texas for more than a decade, added.

“So what you have is his case in black and white in front of a judge. A judge is saying, ‘Hey, here’s a person who fell behind month after month. I don’t care if he paid up; we’re sick of this, sick of these folks falling behind,’” she continued. “My client is just unfortunate that his case fell in the middle of this battle and this change in law. ... Why this is happening: The law is allowing it to happen. It’s not a crooked judge. She’s not racist, she’s not hateful, she’s not trying to kill all deadbeats. My client is not some deadbeat manipulating the system, but he unfortunately fell in the court of a judge that’s getting tired of the problem.”

memphis_069
Attorney Tyesha Elam with client Clifford Hall in June 2014 after he received the Father of the Year Award from the Committed Fathers Alliance

Courtesy of Tyesha Elam 

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.