In her memoir, Caroline recounts in vivid detail how she connected with and came to know her birth mother, Carol “Cookie” Cole, the eldest of Nat King Cole’s four children, and ultimately develop an almost magical relationship with her. (She never knew her grandfather, the legendary singer, who died a few months after she was born.) Though, for many, discovering that you are kin essentially to black royalty would send you over the moon, the celebrity of her background was of little interest to Caroline. Meeting her birth mother, however, brought a depth of recognition and connection that proved to be even more profound than her childhood dreams.
Living 3,000 miles from each other, with neither of them fond of flying, these two women, 20 years apart in age, swapped countless postcards, letters, photos, gifts and stories that now live in their own file cabinet in Caroline’s home office. Their get-to-know-each-other love affair is one that rarely happens with such ease. (Caroline is careful to point out that many such meetings with birth parents turn sour fast.)
Within the pages of this beautifully told story, Caroline grapples with all manner of issues of identity, from discovering her birth mother and learning that she really did love her and never wanted to give her away to learning that her father is Jewish—another story that completely rocked the world of someone who had been assured that she was 100 percent black.
Caroline says she understands why her parents lied to her about this part of her story. “At the time I was adopted, biracial children fell into something of a difficult-to-adopt category,” she says. “Typically, back then, of course, they would be placed in black homes because there was no ‘biracial’ back then. It was the old rules that if you’re half of black, you’re black. My parents, I think, were counseled not to divulge the truth, and they didn’t. I was raised black in a black family, very happily, proudly, adamantly black. And finding out that my birth father was white was jolting.”
As for her birth father, Caroline has not tried to find him. “I knew that a woman carried me for nine months and gave birth smack in the middle of Christmas Day. No woman is going to forget that. So I knew in calling her, although it was going to be a shock, it wasn’t going to literally be out of the blue. In my birth father’s case, it’s very different. He never knew she was pregnant.”
To the question of why a very private person would share so fully about her own adoption story, Caroline says, “I just want to say to people, we all have shadowy parts of our lives where people tell us ‘Leave it be.’ You don’t want to look there, you don’t want to go there, you don’t need to know. And I think it’s worth uncovering who you are. It’s not to say that everything you find out is going to be perfect and it’s all going to go beautifully, but it’s going to make you more whole, and it’s going to help you heal in ways that you may not even have known you needed healing.
“I didn’t think I had this deep need to know, but in knowing, I realized it was more the need that I was never willing to acknowledge,” she continues. “And for Cookie, my showing up proved an incredibly healing thing because here’s this woman who’d been forced to give up a child, who suffered tremendous trauma around that moment because her father died right afterward. She hadn’t been able to see him, be with him for months before that, because she was sequestered in a home across the country as a single pregnant woman, and it changed the course of her life in countless ways.
“My coming back to her was something she had longed for and prayed for, and it was a gift,” Caroline adds. “I mean, it was a gift to her. It was a gift to me, and I hope the story will be a gift to a lot of other people for a lot of different reasons.”