No, ‘Niggardly’ Isn’t the N-Word

A black Brit on his way to the U.S. wants to know if his use of the word will be offensive—and whether he should care.

Posted:
 
75286930

Bill Pugliano

“Niggardly.” Go on, I dare you. Say it. Savor those syllables. Let your tongue caress those consonants. If you’re black and reading this, you may well have just laughed, smiled knowingly, been confused or even taken offense, depending on the size of your vocabulary. If you’re white and reading this, you will probably have just experienced a mild frisson of linguistic danger, as you are either fully aware of the ramifications that your verbalizing the word might have if misconstrued, or dumb enough to think that you’re being genuinely offensive.

When, exactly, is it acceptable to use the word “niggardly”? I speak as someone who loves language, but also as someone who loves people. I’m an ardent humanist and would never seek to offend another’s feelings gratuitously.

I speak, too, as a black Briton about to move to New York to pursue his career in the U.S., but also as a proud heir to the ornate vocabulary of some of our greatest English writers, like Chaucer, Shakespeare, Milton, Johnson, Gibbon and Dickens, all of whom have used the word in their respective works.

Let us be very clear at the outset. “Niggardly” means parsimonious or stingy and is derived from the Old Norse language. “Niggardly,” as you will thankfully already know or will doubtless be relieved to hear, is not related to the Latin word for black—“niger”—and thus is in no way etymologically connected to the deeply pernicious, pejorative racial epithet known in common parlance as the n-word.

Ignorance of this particular homophone has led to some unfortunate reactions from people who hear the word. Most famously, in Washington, D.C., in 1999, a white mayoral aide was asked to resign (but then later had his resignation rescinded) for using the word in front of a mixed audience.

“Niggardly” and its usage throw up many fascinating linguistic, social and racial questions. In today’s highly racialized landscape, is it ever appropriate for a white person to use the word, given the obnoxious history of the racial epithet it unfortunately sounds like?

And what about a black person using it? Should we choose to steer clear of the word altogether, for fear of offending any of our etymologically less well-informed brothers and sisters, or should we use it and be damned, sticking up for the power of language, nonchalantly dismissing raised eyebrows or quizzical expressions?

I also speak as someone who for the last 10 years has been a volunteer mentor to black teenagers in Peckham, a deprived, inner-city London neighborhood. We start off every week with a vocabulary slot where we learn new words, because I fundamentally believe that language is power.

My rationale is very simple: The more words young people have in their mental arsenals, the better they will be able to articulate their thoughts. Moreover, the wider their vocabularies, the more seriously they will be taken by others, especially those with the power to offer them college places and jobs. We always teach the word “niggardly” so that, informed of its correct meaning and provenance, these young people will not react foolishly on hearing it in conversation.

As a respectful visitor to your shores, I am curious about the socio-linguistic etiquette of using the word “niggardly.” On coming to America, should I employ the word liberally, as I do here in London; banish it from my daily lexicon, for fear of being misunderstood; or preface it each time with an erudite, long-winded and what might be construed as pompous etymological explanation? To use or not to use the word “niggardly”: That is the question.

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.
Must-See Family Attractions
July 29 2014 2:13 PM