Why Ads for Blacks Backfire

A controversial viral campaign from Summer's Eve proves that the ad industry still doesn't understand black consumers.

Posted:
 
vaginahand400

A roll of the eyes. A shake of the head. A sigh of disgust. Whatever your reaction may have been to Summer's Eve's latest viral advertisements, you certainly had one.

As part of the personal-hygiene brand's Hail to the V campaign, it released a series of three ads last month featuring talking hands meant to represent vaginas. Using a hand to symbolize a vagina is problematic enough, but it gets worse: The three hands represented a black woman, a Latina and a white woman, with personalities that could have come straight out of a handbook of racial and ethnic stereotypes.

While the white hand-vagina is health conscious and advocates using Summer's Eve after a workout, the Latina vagina has an accent and opens her commercial by saying, "Ay yi yi." She even suggests getting rid of your "tacky leopard thong." Black vagina urges you to stop spending so much time styling your hair and focus on your "wunder [sic] down under." And she even manages to get a neck roll and an "mm-hmm" in before requesting you use some cleansing wash to keep your lady parts fresh before hitting the club.

The commercials caused an uproar. Ad execs and consumers were baffled that Summer's Eve -- which weathered another storm last year after releasing an ad that suggested its products would give women confidence to ask for a raise -- would use such offensive depictions to sell products. Though the company held strong for a few days against harsh criticism, it decided to pull the black and Latina versions of the ads. But even after removing the online ads, Summer's Eve didn't apologize for offending millions of black and Latina vaginas (excuse me, women).

In a statement to AdWeek, Stan Richards of the Richards Group, the agency that created the campaign, said, "We are surprised that some have found the online videos racially stereotypical. We never intended anything other than to make the videos relatable, and our in-house multicultural experts confirmed the approach."

Presumably, the black talking vagina was intended to appeal to the black woman -- to be relatable. I'm a black woman with a black (nontalking) vagina, and I was not amused, entertained or compelled to purchase Summer's Eve products. And it's safe to assume that Latinas didn't give a thumbs-up to their "Ay yi yi" ad. Advertisers can't really think they're relating to us when they use blatant, negative stereotypes. Can they?

But even if the ads failed the relatability test, did they fail to promote the product? David W. Brown of Brown Partners, a minority-owned advertising and marketing firm in Philadelphia, is reluctant to go that far. "It all depends on what the campaign was intended to do. It is definitely getting broader exposure as a result of getting pulled than if it was a straight-up media buy."

If attention was the desired effect, then the commercials were definitely a success. But Summer's Eve isn't the only company that goes too far in the quest to create a buzz.

"This is not the first time, and of course it won't be the last time" that a company uses stereotypes to sell a product, says Al Anderson, founder of Anderson Communications and a 43-year marketing and advertising professional. "This is just a long history of disrespectful advertising. [General-market advertisers] think they know everything about us, when they know nothing."

Back in the day, companies sold products using gross caricatures of blacks -- exaggerated red lips, bulging eyes -- and capitalized on stereotypes about blacks' intelligence. Today we have ads that are less blatantly racist but just as offensive.

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.
Must-See Family Attractions
July 29 2014 2:13 PM