Michael Vick's Lucky Second Chance

Barack Obama is doling out congrats to the Eagles for giving Michael Vick a second chance after prison. But what about "average felons" who don't play sports? Where's their second chance?

Posted:
 
mike20vick400
Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

There has been a loud outcry in the wake of President Obama's recent comments about star Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Michael Vick's post-prison second chance, with protesters falling primarily into one of two camps. They're either shouting, "He's only getting a second chance because he can play football!" Or they're bellowing, "He doesn't deserve a second chance because he's a dog killer!"

The first argument might be true, but it just proves how difficult life can be for convicted felons trying to re-enter society. The second argument suggests that after prison, a convicted felon's "debt to society" should accrue like interest on a credit card that's never paid off.

Critics fail to realize -- or don't care -- that the issue is larger than Vick, whose extraordinary athleticism virtually guaranteed him another shot at success after jail. The real conversations that Obama's comments should spark have nothing to do with former quarterbacks and everything to do with former prisoners.

The media frenzy started after Obama called Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie to have a conversation -- according to a White House statement released Dec. 27 (in response to the firestorm) -- about "plans for the use of alternative energy at Lincoln Financial Field, during which they spoke about that and other issues." The statement was issued after reports turned up that Obama had called Lurie to praise the Eagles for giving Vick an opportunity to play after his release from prison. According to Peter King of Sports Illustrated and NBC, Lurie said the president was "passionate" about the fact that "it's never a level playing field for prisoners when they get out of jail. And he was happy that we did something on such a national stage that showed our faith in giving someone a second chance after such a major downfall."

Apparently some folks believe that every tongue should curse and every heart should hate at the mention of Michael Vick's name. Fox News analyst Tucker Carlson went as far to say that Vick "should have been executed" for dogfighting crimes, for which he spent 18 months in federal prison. "He went to jail for two years. I mean, whatever," Carlson said. "I think the president should be quiet on this one."

Bill Smith, the founder of an animal shelter near Philadelphia, downplayed the lifeline Lurie extended to Vick. "This isn't about giving anyone a second chance," Smith told the Los Angeles Times. "It's about who can make the Eagles organization more money." Washington Post columnist Richard Cohen also questioned Lurie's motives. "It helps, I think, that Vick has completed 63.2 percent of his NFL passes and has 20 touchdowns," Cohen wrote. "He is not your average felon." Cohen went on to recount the grisly details of Vick's offenses, concluding that "he's a thug."

Of course the Eagles' interest was fueled by Vick's rocket arm and fancy feet. If not Lurie, another owner would have rolled the dice in hopes of coming up with a potential league MVP. The bigger question is, would anyone have hired Vick for a job if he weren't an amazing athlete?

 

Many of us know siblings, uncles or best friends' cousins who run into dead ends on job interviews once their criminal records arise. The ripple effect on mothers and children, as well as cities with high rates of incarceration, is staggering: Family income is 15 percent lower the year after a father is released, compared with the year before he went away. And the recession has only exacerbated matters.

So instead of defending his praise for Lurie and Vick, Obama should be defending the "Second Chance Act" and calling for more employers to hire former prisoners. That could lead to more success stories from "average felons" like Timothy Gallagher, one of nine ex-offenders who were pardoned by Obama because of their exemplary work after they were convicted. Gallagher, who served time for a 1982 drug conviction, eventually returned to the Phoenix Fire Department and rescued two people in a memorable blaze. "All of this wouldn't have been possible without a second chance," he told the National Journal.

Comments
The Root encourages respectful debate and dialogue in our commenting community. To improve the commenting experience for all our readers we will be experimenting with some new formats over the next few weeks. During this transition period the comments section will be unavailable to users.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your continued support of The Root.

While we are experimenting, please feel free to leave feedback below about your past experiences commenting at The Root.
The Root 100 People's Choice Awards  
Sept. 19 2014 8:34 AM