A Conversation with A.C. Thompson

A journalist talks about white paranoia and why Mayor C. Ray Nagin is partly to blame for vigilante justice during Katrina.


America has never had a terribly forthright relationship with its history. No surprise, then, that three years after Katrina laid bare the deep, deadly inequality festering in our nation’s cities, we’ve already blotted the memory. In a breathtaking article in this week’s edition of The Nation magazine (reprinted today in The Root), investigative reporter A.C. Thompson does his best to remind us all just how lasting the disaster was for black folks—and how many urgent issues remain unaddressed. Not least of them is a string of vigilante executions that New Orleans law enforcement has, at best, ignored and possibly encouraged.

Thompson brings readers up close with the white vigilantes themselves, who brag about their murderous reign over the Algiers Point neighborhood that the National Guard designated as an evacuation site. Thompson’s reporting reverses the once-popular narrative of black lawlessness in the days after the storm: As order broke down, white residents’ fears and fantasies about black people justified an orchestrated campaign of anti-black terrorism—a too-common scenario that I’ve written about  here at The Root, as well.

The Color of Change has started a petition demanding that these murders finally get investigated. I spoke with Thompson yesterday about his reporting and what it means for the city’s future.

Wright: The first thing that stands out to me is the paranoia in the voice of the militiamen. Their fears of black people seem to justify any action that follows.

Thompson: One thing that came across to me was that people didn’t know each other very well. You had white folks in a neighborhood who didn’t know their black neighbors who lived a couple blocks away. There was this chasm between races, and I think that may have fed the fear that people had.

But another thing that was whipping up hysteria at the time were the media reports—and some of the worst media offenders were Mayor Ray Nagin and Ed Compass, who was then the police chief. They were saying the sky is falling; there is mass disorder and horrible behavior out there. And what the vigilantes told me is, “We heard this stuff on TV, and we thought it was the apocalypse.” Multiple white people told me also they were listening to one radio station that was still on and people were calling the radio station and reporting these horrible things that had supposedly occurred. It turned out that a lot of these things were completely apocryphal—were rumors of rumors of rumors. Yet these things are going on the air, so they have this imprimatur of the media.

Wright: You said in the article you’ve spent 10 years reporting crime and have never seen anything like this in terms of uninvestigated cases.

Thompson: It’s very rare that people will admit to you, “Oh, I witnessed this serious felony or shooting or attempted murder.” It’s very rare that you’ll find people who’ll say, “I was the victim of this shooting.” And it’s even more rare that you’ll find people in all positions—people who witnessed shootings, people who participated in shootings and people who were victims of shootings—and speak to them and find out that none of them have ever talked to a cop. It was mind-boggling to me. I was flabbergasted. When people give detailed information about serious, serious felonies and they’re credible and they’re perfectly willing to share it with you, it’s very confusing and pretty amazing to realize that no law enforcement official has ever visited this person and asked them what they know.

Wright: So do you suspect or have any evidence of collusion with the police?